Green Eggs and Ham: A Reading Exercise

I’d been out of the womb perhaps fifteen minutes, still focusing my eyes, wondering what school, I was going to, and wishing for a cup of coffee… when Mom decided to go into education. Not right AWAY, of course; there was a baby to take care of. She prepared for this by buying books on teaching… and teaching me to read.

I don’t remember any of this, of course. She would tell the stories later in my life. I don’t recall anything but the stories. But I also cannot remember a time when I could not read. In my memories, going waaaay back to four, five, six years old? I already knew how to read. I remember being surprised when I found out that other kids COULDN’T read. Mighod, what’s WRONG with you people?

And this led to the Christmas weekend with Aunt Lee, a tale that my mother loved to tell.

We were visiting my grandparents, and my elderly great aunt Lee was there, and of course, everyone had to dote on the baby for a while and then go off and make grownup talk while drinking strange smelly beverages that I did not like. That was okay. I’d brought along a stacka Dr. Seuss, and I was good, so I climbed up on the sofa, opened up the book, and began the familiar tale of Sam I Am, who preached the gospel of strangely colored breakfast foods. I am told I was a bit past three, at the time. The grownups were, if I remember the story correctly, playing bridge.

And Aunt Lee glanced at the couch, and was captivated. “Oh, that is precious,” she said. “Look at him. He’s pretending to read a book. Someone get a camera.”

“He’s not pretending,” said Mom. “That’s one of his favorite books.”

“Oh, pshaw,” said Lee. “He’s not old enough to read.”

“Honey, read the book to your Aunt Lee,” Mom said, to me.

“Well, on the first page,” I said, "Sam I Am doesn’t say anything, but he holds up a sign. It says ‘I am Sam.’ And then he turns it around and it says ‘Sam I Am.’ "

“Well, that doesn’t prove anything,” said Lee. “You’ve probably read him that book a thousand times. He knows it by heart. He’s not reading, he’s reciting.”

“So pick any book out of his stack,” said Mom. “You think he’s memorized them ALL? He’ll read aloud to you out of any of them.”

“Are you willing to put your money where your mouth is?” said Lee, laying down her cards.

“I know my son can read,” said Mom, laying down her own.

“Ten bucks says I can prove he can’t read.”

“You’re on.”

“And I pick the reading material.”

“Fine.”

Lee got up and walked over to a shelf where my grandfather kept several decades worth of old Reader’s Digest magazines. Mom balked a bit, “Now, Lee, he’s NOT a rocket scientist…”

“You don’t think he can read words in a row?”

“Dammit, I know he can read–”

“Then let him read. Ten bucks says he can’t.”

The two women haggled a bit before settling on a page of text without too many polysyllables on it, and the two of them approached me on the couch. “Honey,” said Mom, “Would you read this section aloud for your aunt?”

I took the little magazine and looked at it. Mom pointed at the top of the page.

“L… laaa… laaff-ter… is the best m… med… medicine,” I said. I knew what medicine was, but I’d never seen the word before. Laughter, though, THAT one I knew; that was the one with the GH in the middle that didn’t make any sense, but you read it like it was an F, because that was the rules.

Mom, in later years, would describe Lee’s face with great relish; to hear her tell it, the old woman’s eyes got very large, her smile vanished into the ozone, and her actual face got about three inches longer than it should have been. Obliviously, I kept reading.

“One day,” I said, “A p… pa… pat… pat-ee-ent…”

“Pay-shunt,” corrected my mother.

“Quiet,” commanded Aunt Lee.

“One day, a patient came into my off… office,” I read. “I had seen him a month ear… ear… earlier, and he had sur-jur-ree at the time and had come for a fol… follow-up visit…”

Mom would later describe (with no little glee) Lee’s face as stunned, open-mouthed, and faintly horrified; this was a thing that should not BE.

“What’s ‘surgery,’ Mommy?” I asked.

“Would you like him to keep going?” said my mother sweetly. “I’m sure he doesn’t know all the words, but I know damn well he can read them at you.”

Mom would later describe Lee’s eyes as “a bit bugged out, and they looked like burnt holes in a blanket.” Without another word, Lee went to her purse and pulled out a tenner and slapped it on the table. “I am convinced,” she said. “Did YOU teach him to do that?”

“Do you want me to keep going?” I asked.

Lee looked at me with faint suspicion. Mom smiled. “No, sweetie, you did fine.”

“I did the best I could,” I said. “There were no pictures.”

“I know, sweetie, you did just fine,” said Mom. “Now put your shoes on. Your aunt is taking us out for ice cream.”

My mother told that story for many years after it happened, both to me, to others, and to the students she would one day have when she became a teacher. And she always told it with the same glee as I’d heard in her voice the first time. Not sure if it was pride in her son’s reading ability, or winning a ten dollar bet back when ten bucks MEANT something, but she’d considered it a victory, either way.

As I grew older, I got rather chummy with my Aunt Lee, and I still remember the time SHE told me that story… with the same particulars, but from her own point of view.

“And I stood there, looking at a tiny baby, holding a book and reading at me out of it,” she said, “and for one cold, scary moment, I was sure I was lookin’ at a crimbil .”

“A what?” I said.

“A crimbil, dear.”

“What’s a crimbil?”

My aged Aunt Lee smiled at me. “You’re a smart boy, dear,” she said. “Go look it up.”

OK, that beats when Mom’s copy of Mrs. Frisby and the Rats of NIMH went missing when I was five years old, and I spent the next week updating her on what the rats were up to now.

:smiley: that’s awesome!

I also have no conscious memory of not being able to read. I wonder how common that is?

I have a somewhat similar story, about a time when my mom’s friend didn’t believe I was reading Through the Looking Glass, because I was turning the pages too fast. So my mom timed her reading a page of the book, then me, then quizzed us on the contents. I won both parts of that contest.

My sister’s boy came home from his first day of school disappointed that they didn’t teach him to read right away. They just gave him that “alphabet” jazz.

He remembers the incident and is amused by it nowadays, but he clearly remembers a time when he could not read. I can’t. I still remember being able to read the credits on TV shows and the names of products advertised on TV when I couldn’t even reach the kitchen counter.

I have precisely the opposite story, often told to me although I don’t remember it.

One day, my mother is beset by a grave face when she comes to pick up lil’ Johnny from preschool. It seems that Johnny is causing trouble! He’s being a real pest.

Mom is concerned What’s the problem?

“Well,” says the preschool lady. “Lil’ Johnny won’t participate in the reading lessons.”

“Oh no!” says Mom. “Why not?”

“He just wants to play.

Mom looks down at me. “Lil’ Johnny,” says she. “Is this true?”

I nod.

“Why don’t you want to read?”

“Because,” I say peevishly. “I’m four.

Mom nods at me and looks back to the preschool lady.

“He’s right. He’s four. Let him play. See you tomorrow!”

Did I mention that mom is an early childhood education specialist? I never got away with anything school-related, but more than one teacher over the years would come to regret calling her in without excellent reasons and the documentation to back it up. She was an equal-opportunity iron fist.

I do remember (or remember remembering…) a time when I could only proto-read: I could see what the first letter of a word was, and its length, and try to guess it from context.

I can’t remember being conscious of not being able to read. But considering I have maybe two dozen memories, total, from before I learned to read, that’s not really surprising.

OTOH, I remember learning to read. I was four and a half years old, and my older sister had just started first grade. She practiced her reading in the evenings by reading each word aloud as she put her finger under that word. I watched from over her shoulder, and I just kind of absorbed it. That’s how I learned to read.

I don’t remember a time when I couldn’t read - according to my family it was before I turned three. My father was very proud that I could read at such a young age, but if he had ever imagined he could have won money betting on my being able to read, he would have been a lot prouder.

I was read to a lot as a kid, and was being given things like Highlights and Humpty Dumpty magazine at age 3 and 4. I picked up a ton of info that way (some hysterically incorrect, some right on the money). No formal reading lessons, but I picked that skill up from the pics and being read to.

Then one day, in the presence of my mom and my aunt Mip and a few cousins, my aunt was reciting kiddie rhymes to us. She did the traditional “Humpty Dumpty” recital. “Humpty Dumpty sat on a wall, Humpty Dumpty had a great fall. All the king’s horses and all the king’s men couldn’t put Humpty together again.”

What she didn’t anticipate was my response when she finished. In my 4 year old voice, I quoted from memory, having read it in my Humpty Dumpty magazine: “But then came a doctor with patience & glue, and put Humpty together, better than new. Now he’s happy and healthy and back on the scene, and busily editing this magazine!”

Mom later told me aunt Mip (who had never heard that particular verse before) looked like she thought I was some sort of oracle, with the gods speaking through me. Much fuss was made, and I ate it up.

Hee, hee. Johnny_Bravo, yez makes me feel good.

Me, too! I have one conscious memory of not being able to read well, and it involves one particular sentence from The House At Pooh Corner: “I’m face down under something, and that, Piglet, is a very bad position for looking at ceilings.”

Having not really mastered either long words or punctuation conventions, I remember trying to make sense of And that Piglet is a very bad person for looking at sellings? cereals?

This is similar for me. I don’t remember not being able to read, but I do remember learning how. The Montessori method is rather repetitive*, so it’s hard to forget. I learned in kindergarten, and was reading the (kids) dictionary by the end there, even learning how to pronounce words.

*You don’t learn the same thing over and over, but you learn each piece the same way. You learn all the sounds that individual letters make, then move on to applying them to 3 letter words, then to longer words, then you learn sounds combinations make.

Edit: Wait, I just remembered after I wrote this, that I do remember one time not being able to read, though I couldn’t tell you how old I was. Mom read Goodnight Moon to me every night, and I wanted to read it myself. But I had memorized it.

But it’s not a first person memory. It’s just a fact in my brain.

When I was maybe 4 or 5 my dad was reading Dr. Suess’ Sleep Book to my sister. I knew the book by heart, having heard it read to me many times. I don’t think I could read it yet, but I had it memorized. In the middle of the book, I started reciting it along with my dad. My parents were floored that I had the whole book memorized.

Some time later, in school, my teacher was reading the same book to the class. At one point she made a mistake: she read the line “they’re talking their heads off” as “they’re taking their heads off”. The class roared with laughter. I was extremely upset about her mistake, and at the fact that the erroneous line had gotten a laugh. I wanted to correct her, but knew that I would not be applauded for my correction by either the teacher or the class. I stayed silent, but it bothered me for a long time (actually it still sorta does).

The first words I recall reading were “Sklar Obstetrical Forceps—Stainless Steel.”

And then I felt a great tug on my head.

I also have no memory of not reading. When I was small (preschool) my sister read to me a lot. Mother was concerned that my reading skills would be below par because of this.

In fact, the opposite happened. In Junior School, I would be suspected of cheating when I read a book in a day, but simple questions proved that I had not only read it but could describe the plot etc.

Thanks a lot… dabs at the coffee stain on my shirt

I’m the same way, and I expect my brother and sister are as well. There’s a family story we have, where one of our first teachers sent home a note, asking, “Why does this child already know how to read?” I suspect it was about my sister, but I forget the exact details.

I recall staring at a cereal box and suddenly being able to read the ingredients.

I remember “reading” Go Dog Go before kindergarten, but I don’t recall if I was reading it or just reciting what had been read to me. Nobody even bothered to tell me how my name was spelled until I was five.