People had complained they were confused about who said what in which thread, and I agree, one thread per topic is plenty, usually.
The two choices are:
(a) close one thread (which I did) and route new traffic to the other thread (which I did) -or-
(b) merge the two threads.
I’m not familiar enough with them (and I don’t intend to become so) to know whether merging them would be better or worse solution, so I request your votes. Do you prefer the status quo (option (a)) or would you like me to merge the threads (option (b).) Post your votes here, one vote per player, please.
Merge 'em. What the hell, if Harry Potter fans can read hundreds of pages and discuss them at length in less than a week then they can handle an extra-long thread with some redundancy.
merge so that nothing is lost. I know I have probably cross posted, and I am sure I am not the only one. This way, nobody makes a reference (in future) that noone else can find.
I vote to merge, seeing as that one is at 3 pages and the other at 4.
I think locking one down works better for situations where there are only a few posts in one or both of the threads. With 3 + pages, it’s clear that people put a lot of effort into their questions, comments, and analysis. Keeping the content alive in one combined thread seems best to me.
What’s essentially wrong with two threads? The topic is obviously popular enough to justify it. If people get confused which is which, then good. Keeping 'em straight will be a profitable intellectual exercise.
I’d like to obtain some clarification of what happens to post order when something such as this is done. Does the server make note of the time of each post, and order them thusly, or do the three pages of the (presently-closed) thread get tacked onto wherever the currently-open thread ends when the operation is performed?
'Cause I have a post that refers to one of my prior posts by number, and if that number changes, the whole reference goes into a cocked hat. Still, greater good and all that.
Merge, baby. Even though there are many cross-posts/posters, people won’t have to read two different threads and/or post in both threads. Ideas from one thread may not be in the other. So, merge.