Has anyone tried Gemini For Home on older devices?

I have these older Google Assistant smart speakers that still do a fine job of answering questions, playing music, etc. One is an early Google Home Mini and the other two are Best Buy house branded speakers. Oh, and I have a JBL branded smart speaker, too!

Google is constantly pushing changing to Gemini for Home, but I’m worried it’s going to brick these, or make them much worse.

Does anyone have experience with Gemini for Home? How about on older devices?

Answering myself here, I asked Gemini what are the pluses and minuses and it is telling me to hold off until Google requires me to “upgrade”. Apparently, Gemini for Home is slower, and much worse at music requests (Hey Google, shuffle my Ska playlist). It’s better at complex smart home requests, but I have no smart home devices (other than these).

Also, you have to have the same voice respond, no matter who asks the question, and there’s no voice match. Right now, if my wife or son as for a song, it uses their Spotify account, so it doesn’t mess up what I’m listening to elsewhere. Sounds like that ability will be gone. Seems like a non-starter.

Also, I like having my Aussie voice responses, and my wife likes whatever voice she picked out. I’d hate to lose those customizations.

I assume I’ll be forced to “upgrade” soon. Enshittification continues apace.

I was forced to upgrade on some devices. I hate it a lot. Gemini sucks at what the Google Assistant was good at (setting alarms, controlling music, etc.) while also being crap at what real AI is good at (complex conversations and tasks).

It’s the worst of both worlds, some Google project manager’s fuck you to all their users.

I would avoid it as long as possible if I were you. Eventually you’ll be forced to upgrade. I basically stopped using it after that instead of trying to use Gemini. It’s terrible now.


I have a distant relative who works at Google. I complained to them about how bad the new one was, and they refused to believe me. I showed them a side by side demo of how much worse the new one is for something like setting an alarm. He then dismissed it as “oh well, who does that anyway? how many times a day do you need to do that?” (MANY!)

I don’t think anyone there cares about normal people anymore. They live in their own crazy bubble.

Ugh. Thanks for the feedback and I’ll definitely hold off as long as possible.