God fucking damnit, people. (And I usually avoid using God like that.) When someone comes in and drops a rant about something that really upsets them, how shitty a person do you have to be to come in and call them a liar? If you have a personal problem with the guy, so that you think he’s less than trustworthy, come out and say what it is.
But we all know what it’s really about. “Look at how smart I am! I didn’t believe this one perfectly plausible.” Never mind that you have absolutely no evidence that it is false. Never mind that we’ve had plenty of pit threads about people just like this neighbor–ones you didn’t self stimulate about not believing.
It’s a fucking rant. We all know there’s more than one side. It doesn’t make you better to point that out. It shows you’re just spoiling for a fight. It shows that you are, like the neighbor, someone who freaks out about unimportant shit.