Oh, I don’t know. She was all smiles, remember, and announced that she’d pee’d. Sometimes you need an extreme reaction to get things through to your kids. We so often handle situations with such deference to the feelings of our children, that we make no impression upon them at all.
One of my co-workers is having this problem with her child…she and her husband are so afraid of hurting the little darling’s delicate psyche that they are nearly on the verge of divorce due to sleep deprivation. The precious angel has manipulated them into hopping to her beck and call at all hours throughout the night, for the most inane reasons…but the child says things in such a “cute” way they feel they can’t say no to her…and if she gets frustrated she does this coughing thing until she throws up. They let her manipulate them until they snap at each other in frustration…but I have the feeling that if one time they snapped at the kid instead, things might change.
And mean can be effective. My confession: back when my daughter was a 2 year old, we lived in Georgia. It was summer, and very hot, and I was extremely pregnant, and the air-conditioning was inadequate. My daughter was going through potty-training, and developed this thing about being wet…not just in the panties, but anywhere on her clothes. If a drop of water fell from her lips onto her shirt while she was drinking, she demanded to change her clothes…would get hysterical until she was in dry clothes. Now it’s summer in Georgia…that water drop will dry in two minutes. But no…she had to change clothes. This would happen multiple times a day. One very hot day, not long before I gave birth to an overdue, 9-lb baby (yeah, I’m trying to paint a picture of extreme discomfort and raging hormones to make myself look better) she pulled that crap again…four tiny drops of water down her shirt, and she started herself a hissy. I lost it. I went into the bathroom, drew a cup of water, walked back down the hall to where she was and said something to the effect that if she thought that was wet, get a load of this…and threw the water right in her face and all over her shirt. Of course she burst into tears, and so did I, and I hugged her and sobbed and apologized…but I also told her she had pushed me too far…and I wouldn’t let her change clothes. We went outside to play, and she dried off in minutes, and she never, ever, ever tried that stunt again. Ever. Not once.
She also did not seem to be traumatized by the event. No tears, no bringing it up again, no fear of Mommy with a cup of water in her hand, no avoidance of the sprinkler or the hose or the pool…okay, she did refuse to learn how to swim until she was twelve, but that’s a different issue…she went into water with alacrity…just refused to take lessons (ballet as well). So last year I came clean with her about this incident…and she has no memory of it, at all. She’s 25. She’s fine. She loves me, and I didn’t harm her…in fact, I’m sure I kept myself from harming her worse by ending that behavior. Was it mean? Absolutely. Was it harmful? No, it was water…that’s the point! Was she in control of her actions at that time? Yes and no…she was two, but two-year-olds can be the most manipulative things on earth, unless we let them know they are out of line. That’s why we are the parents, and they are kids. Do I regret doing it? Yes and no. It worked. I never forgot the stunned look on her face. And I wish some of the logical, reasoning things we had tried in the weeks leading up to this had worked. But it finally took her seeing my rage, and being scared, to change her behavior. Which meant she had control of the behavior from the beginning…she just wasn’t convinced she needed to change.