Boom. That’s it for me. Her hawkishness, her assertions that there was only so much that could be done to advance progressive causes and folks on the left should just settle (especially when it came to the Don’t Ask Don’t Tell compromise), and her utter stiffness as a politician turned me off from her. That said, I’m Canadian and never had the chance, but I would have yanked that lever for her in 2016 with great urgency because while she was in the comprehensible spectrum of “disappointing but what are you gonna do?” politicians, the other option was horrific. I was also a big Klobuchar fan, and quite like Kamala Harris, and I think the latter has really gotten the shaft from this administration in terms of her portfolio.
I always felt that folks didn’t get about Hillary Clinton was that people, politician or not, can be two different and seemingly contradictory things at once. That she could be the caring, child-of-the-sixties, forward looking politician with a desire to break the glass ceiling for women, that would meet someone in a crowd of fans who asked her for help on some issue and she’d immediately task her staff with resolving some burning injustice. And at the same time, she could also be revealed on tape to be a money-grubbing shill for Wall Street interests, who would take a quarter million for a speech in which she laughingly tells a room of bankers that she can’t explain the public the kind of things she’s telling them right now, and she does have their interests at heart, don’t worry about it. Both people can exist in the same body, but many people will only see one of those and base their entire opinion on it.
As for forgiving her husband for his repeated infidelities…personally, that rankled me the most. I’ve been cheated on and I know how devastating it is, and I wouldn’t stay with someone who strayed, so I can’t totally get into her headspace. I also have a number of married friends who live a polyamorous lifestyle, so I know there exist open consentual marriages. While I don’t think she and Bill ever had that, I do think that at some point in the late seventies or early eighties there was a conversation that went something like this.
“Look Hil, I guess you know this about me, I’ve always been a dog. I can’t help it, it’s just the way I’m wired. I love you, and I love Chelsea, more than anything. But it’s just in my nature to dip my pen in the company ink any chance I get. I’d understand if you want to leave, though I know it’ll hurt both of us career-wise, you more than me. For that, I’m truly sorry.”
“Alright Bill. I get that, and I think I always knew. And I know, that especially here in the South, I’ll come out the worse for it. So here’s my deal. I understand that you’ll have your adventures. I don’t like it, but that’s reality. Unless you cross an insane line with public scandal, I’ll stay with you and play the loyal Christian forgiving wife to maintain what support we can among the bubbas and bubbettes. But in return, you’re going to go balls-to-the-wall for me in supporting my political career. I’m not stopping at First Lady, there are a lot of class ceilings to break, and you’re going to give me your undying support and lend your downright creepy charisma to my campaigns. There’s the deal.”
I have zero evidence that conversation ever happened, but I’m convinced there was some kind of deal between them. And as someone who can’t get with a non-monogamous lifestyle (but different strokes), that soured me on her as well.