[QUOTE=Diogenes the Cynic]
You say these producers are creative, but I don’t see cutting and pasting the work of other people as anything but thievery.
[/quote]
Even though you’re quoting me, I can’t help but feel that you didn’t read my post at all. I posted 2 examples of producers whose material is entirely their own – these producers are 2 of the 3 most successful producers in modern hip-hop (both on the charts and in critics hearts). Neither of these guys sample – your accusations of thievery simply do not apply, and I told you this before you said them a second time. Surely you understand why I’m confused and a little frustrated with your response.
Moreover, anyone who is bitching about samples is sorely mistaken about the state of modern hip-hop. Yes, Kanye brought soul samples, and yes there are a bunch of people on his dick. But when the evidence is right there on the charts I can’t understand why people refuse to consider the facts unless they have some weird addiction to being mistaken and then subsequently shown to be wrong. Look at the hip-hop charts, guys. The amount of new material being originally produced greatly outweighs the amount of new material crafted together through sampling. Whatever metric you choose, popular hip-hop is dominated by original songs.
[QUOTE=wm–]
Opinions about art don’t have to just be a visceral “like it or don’t like it” reaction, they can and do have reasoning behind them.
[/quote]
Certainly. But when it comes to hip-hop many of these reasons are either unsupportable (that creating a hip-hop song requires no talent and cannot be considered art), bizarre hypocrisy (popular hip-hop music is only about dancing, crime, doing drugs, or women; completely unlike pop and rock which are only about dancing, crime, doing drugs, or women), or completely from ignorance that could be easily solved by asking simple questions instead of making assumptions (sorry, Dio, but you’re example #1 here: “I never listen to hip-hop because I don’t like it, but I will simply assume without knowledge that hip-hop producers are thieves who steal”). I do understand that people have their reasons for not liking hip-hop on an aesthetic level. I don’t understand why people insist on claiming that the reasons they hate hip-hop having nothing to do with aesthetics but instead are any combination of the three reasons listed above. Reasoning can be good or bad; the confusing thing is not why people have good reasons, but why they have bad ones.
[QUOTE=Wolfian]
You think Gangster’s Paradise fits in the typical guns and 'hos pattern? Have you ever listened to the song? First lyrics:
As I walk through the valley of the shadow of death
I take a look at my life and realize there’s nothing left,
‘cause I’ve been laughin’ and blastin’ so long
even my momma thinks that my mind is gone.
[/quote]
Uh, yes, it is a gangster rap song, but no I haven’t heard it – I’m basing my opinion off of the wikipedia entry about the controversy surrounding the Weird Al parody. Gangster rap isn’t necessarily rapping about how good it feels to be a gangster (noted exception: Damn it Feels Good to be a Gangster, by the Geto Boys, is necessarily about how good it feels to be a gangster). Many of the greatest (and most popular) songs in gangster rap are cautionary tales about the perils of hood life – consider Ice Cube’s “It was a Good Day,” in which a day is considered to have gone pretty sweet simply because Cube wasn’t killed (and he didn’t even have to use his AK!). Consider roughly half of Tupac’s career. It’s kind of like how “Still Fly” (the funniest song in modern hip-hop) is still a bling song. Kind of like how “Munich” is still a revenge thriller. Cautionary tales are still genre tales.
Oh, and thanks for being snide to a guy for talking about Coolio in response to a direct question about Coolio by another poster (the guy that you were being snide to is me!).