I think violinist/guitarist Lisa Germano deserves mention. I’m having a hard time finding good picture of her from when she was touring with John Mellencamp in the late 80s, but I think these pics get the point across.
Younger Days:
There’s not nearly enough Bruce in this thread.
I have the biggest girl crush on Anna Nalick.
And because long reload times on my crappy connection prevented an edit…
I’m also very pleased to see that people like Johnette, too. I got to see her live in concert a few years ago… well, at least, I was there, and I’m pretty sure that was her on stage. 
She did a duet with some guy whose name I forget – he opened for her, and while I found him rather forgettable, their duet of The Ship Song was breathtaking. I had never heard the song before that.
And Nick Cave. Aiyai. It’s a good thing I find him attractive because it helps me understand why I had a crush on a guy who looks JUST LIKE HIM when I was eighteen.
You won’t hear me saying it about many people, period. But Tommy really does look better with her hair coloured light.
I was lucky like you to find a boy looking really like him at college. I managed to make acquaintance with him, and after a few conversations, he asked me if I knew Nick Cave… “well, yes, of course, I really dig his music” (and why do you think I’m following you everywhere like that ? 
)