I use tahini paste instead of sesame oil – tahini is made from sesame seeds. I scatter a bit of paprika and finely-chopped parsley on the top, and then sprinkle a bit of good olive oil on as well. On the other hand, I don’t add garlic, though that does seem like a reasonable addition to the mixture.
Yeah, I think tahini is kind of central to hummus (at least traditional hummus), so if that’s missing, it would taste a bit off to me. Also, the lack of olive oil would stand out for me. Other than that, I keep it very simple. Chickpeas, tahini, good olive oil, lemon juice, garlic, and salt is all I add. I find hummus doesn’t need anything more than this. Maybe a sprinkle of chile pepper at the end for color.
Hummus made with peanut butter always tastes like peanut butter to me, and nothing else. Natural peanut butter might not be so bad, but it’s worth it to seek out some tahini. It lives in the fridge forever.
Mine is chickpeas, tons of garlic, tahini, cumin, paprika, salt, pepper, lemon juice, and olive oil. It’s worth it to toast the cumin a little before you add it and to use an actual lemon instead of the bottled stuff, IMO.
Even with tahini in it, I’d say it still needs some sesame oil. It has a more roasted flavor than the tahini alone.
You also didn’t mention any salt. I find that I need to add some to the food processor when my wife isn’t looking (she makes it, then asks me to taste/adjust the flavor).
The tahini will really make a difference. I found it tucked away with the ethnic foods (kosher, asian stuff) aisle of Publix. It’s in a brown/orange/white can about the size of small can of peanuts. I also reserve some of the liquid from the drained chick peas to add to the mixture, we like it a bit thinner.
I love lotsa garlic and fresh lemon juice in mine. When it’s finished and chilled I’ll swirl a lil bit of olive oil on top with some paprika with warm pita bread.
/drool
/eyes up remaining tahini in the fridge
/ponders