It’s funny looking at all the “absurd” shows to make porn out of that people have been throwing around in this thread, when I consider that I’ve actually run across porn of most of them. Rule #34 in action.
The website Topless Robot used to have a weekly feature where Rob Bricken would find and offer commentary on erotic fan fiction. Was some really hilarious stuff.
My favorite one will always be the giant squid that had sex with Hogwarts. It’s a classic.
I’m not even going to quote any bits from it because I don’t want to ruin it for anyone. The first time I read it, I laughed so hard I hurt myself.
As for the OP, meh. There’s literally no possible way you can participate in that community and not know what the world at large generally thinks about your “hobby”.
Anyone remember when one of the women who wore a Teletubby suit turned out to have done porn?
I’ve heard that there’s a lot of “Spongebob” and “Cars” pornographic fanfiction. I could definitely see Spongebob and Sandy Cheeks getting it on, and the various car characters too.
My 13-year-old niece is a big “Cars” fan, and for a while, she was writing fanfic with Guido and Luigi’s dialogue translated into Italian using Babelfish.
Oh, c’mon. I’m mostly on the side of “live and let live,” but don’t try and invoke Rule 34. That’s A) a joke and B) a defence / call to arms for pornographying everything that hasn’t been yet.
Nobody’s in danger of living in a world without dirty MLP material. Admit you like it, don’t hide behind 4chan nonsense.
You’re more-or-less right that accusations of pedophilia ignore than the characters in the show are probably (if nebulously) of-age. It is still, broadly speaking, a kid’s show. That’s going to be questionable to people. It’s like making porn of adult characters from Sesame Street. It’s child-adjacent material, and there are people who will react on a visceral level.
So, the answer to your question is a question: how much crap do you want to put up with from other people? If you don’t want to take crap, then you should probably be pretty discrete, if not downright embarassed. If you want to take more crap, then go whole hog. Clop clop clop.
What makes y’all believe the ponies are meant to be sexual beings at all?
The extrapolation from their continued anthropomorphism? They act like us, they talk like us, they express themselves very much like us, their faces are modeled after us…
Hell, even in the context of the show, it’s not like romantic relationships get a pass. Spike is really into Rarity. Trenderhoof has a thing for Applejack that borders on stalking (played for laughs, of course). Then there’s Equestria Girls, where Twilight is clearly crushing on Flash Sentry.
They’re not sexual beings in the show. However, extrapolating from “they’re heavily anthropomorphized animals” to “they have sex” is not some wild leap of faith.
Yeah, it’s weird. So is the sexualization of virtually any canon work that does not explicitly or implicitly bring up the topic of sex. So is most of, well, sexualization in general.
Here’s the thing: you’re the one who brought it up in the first place. Nobody forced you to start this thread, or reveal it here. Now you’re whining about people thinking you’re a perv? You basically opened the door for it.
They’re cartoons. I call it quite a leap.
Not if the characters are presented as human beings in something like the real world.
It is very likely he knew everyone would react this way.
He gets all the attention, plays dumb about sexualizing cartoon horses targeted toward little girls, and most likely will use posters in this thread as inspiration for some character that gets ponyraped in his fanfic.
A safer bet is that he gets off on publicly humiliating himself. Being a regular attention whore isn’t enough.
I’m new here. I don’t know you. I have friends who have written porn. I’ve advised friends on how to purchase event insurance for a BDSM convention. My advice: Don’t tell people. Especially don’t post it on your Facebook feed.
Yeah, lots of people won’t get it. Lots of people will think it is creepy. Potential future employers included. I can’t imagine this idea is novel to you. My friend needed help finding insurance because – shockers – a lot of insurance agencies wouldn’t work with his group.
And no, it never occurred to me that Jesse, from Team Rocket, was hot. Maybe I’m too old for him. Jesse from “Breaking Bad” was hot. I’m too old for him, too, but he looks like an adult to me. Jesse from Team Rocket looked like a kid.
The underage one, or the retarded one? Either way, it’s not really a proud boast.
Whining? I’m trying to clarify the issue to someone who doesn’t get it. Virtually every single person I know qualifies as a perv, apparently. The issue, again, comes down to two main things: I wanted to share this with some people, and figured I might run into some kindred spirits here (god only knows why I keep thinking that, I’m still getting shit over something two years ago that didn’t actually happen), and I wanted to test the waters before sharing this with friends of mine. Went really well. Lesson learned, thank you.
Ponies get married, and have kids. True, the actual “how is babby formed?” process could be a little different, but it’s clearly established that fillies come from parents.
You might consider establishing a presence on a couple other social message boards and then asking there. You might get different responses. . . . or not. Based on this post and some other posters, your past history might be skewing the answer to your question.
Sexual hobbies of all kinds follow the same rules-- do what you like with like-minded, legally consenting company. Otherwise, leave it to yourself. Nobody wants to hear about your sex life. Nobody.
“Hey guys, I combine pedophilia and zoophilia for fun! Is this okay?”
Answer: you know damn well it’s not. But if you want to talk about it, please do. Hopefully that’ll cause you to lose your job and get busted for possession of whatever you have that you shouldn’t have.
Pretty much this. And yes, you should be embarrassed.
Look, he asked for opinions on the hobby, but that doesn’t make him fair game for insults. Save it for the Pit.