I’m sort of considering this the third of a trilogy of recent trump “How?” threads, along with:
-
How can Trump get away with defaming Carroll as a liar today (5/11/2023)?
-
How is Trump not guilty of manslaughter? (Not linked as it is a Pit thread)
In the ‘manslaughter’ thread, I said this and @LSLGuy replied:
In one where “Anyone (R)” gets more followers than “Anyone (D)” because of relentless propaganda and the eletoral advantages of gerrymanderng and the EC. I think there’s not much more to it.
There have been times in the past when people here have said things like “I would vote for a chimp before I’d vote for an R for president”. The other side thinks the same thing. And this time they’re really being asked to vote for their chimp. Even if half of them don’t recognize he’s a chimp. We should be careful what we ask for rhetorically.
I wanted to reply but didn’t want to hijack that thread, so I’m starting my own.
So, trump is far and away the leading Repub candidate, and early polling is showing trump leading Biden in a potential rematch race, with people concerned that Biden doesn’t have the ‘mental sharpness’ for 4 more years. This, to me, is fairly terrifying.
It just boggles my mind that, after all we as a country have gone through with trump, that he’s still, not only a viable candidate, but with only 18 months until the election could very credibly be reelected President. How can this possibly be? trump has done and said things that would sink the political career of any other politician hundreds of times over. his many, many failings and horrible things he’s said and done have been discussed ad nauseum, so I won’t go into detail, but a few highlights:
- trump is a failure politically. As president he accomplished very little legislatively, horribly mismanaged the pandemic, and lost the House in the midterms, the Senate by interfering in the Georgia Senate runoff, and the Presidency. About his only real accomplishment from a ‘R’ point of view is his stacking the Supreme Court and appointing a bunch of Federal judges, but McConnell was mostly the evil mastermind behind the SC stacking, and any R president could have just followed Federalist Society recommendations.
- Virtually everybody who has ever affiliated themselves with trump in business or politically has been burned, many in career-ending ways. trump has thrown formerly loyal sycophants under the bus time and time again. It’s an open secret that many Repubs who publicly support him, actually despise him. When politics is all about ‘political capital’, the very currency of politics, how has this not come back to bite him in the ass?
- and then there are the many, many crimes and multitude of stupid, crazy, racist, malevolent things he has repeatedly said publicly. His election denial and his causing the January 6 riots alone, shaking the core of our Democratic process, should be enough to destroy him politically.
And yet…he has been counted out and declared politically dead many times, and bounces back beating his terrible little drum like some nightmarish Energizer Bunny. Yes, one can argue, “it’s still early in the '24 campaign. trump has his rabid base, but can’t put together enough moderate votes for another win. He lost decisively in 2020.” But even after 4 years of insanity, he had more votes than any sitting president in history, only losing because the Dem base was fired up and even more of them voted for Biden. It’s a very real, very grim possibility that he may pull off a ‘Grover Cleveland’.
What is it that makes him the political equivalent of Jason in the many Friday the 13th sequels? I can only speculate:
- As LSLGuy said, many voters have the attitude “I’d rather vote for a chimp than the other guy” and the Repubs are much better at portraying the other guy as a chimp than Dems are.
- Most voters don’t pay very close attention, have short memories and attention spans, and the old Nazi trusim “repeat a lie enough times and it becomes the truth” comes into play. trump has the name recognition, and those inclined to vote ‘R’ or just not to vote Biden see trump’s bloviating as a sign of ‘strong leadership’.
- Even though trump’s ‘rabid base’ is a minority not able to elect him on their own (I’ve heard an estimate of 25-30% of voters), they love trump because of, not despite, the qualities others despise him for, and will never, ever abandon him. That makes it easier to cobble together a few more moderate votes to put him over the top.
- The ‘Deep State’ conspiracy mongering stuff that trump’s handlers came up with was a particularly evil genius creation, because it auto-inoculates trump against all criticism in those who are inclined to buy the BS. “they’re not against me, they’re against you, and I’m just in the way!”
- trump has an almost feral instinct to sense opponents’ weakness and attack it. That, coupled with his absolute lack of shame that allows him to keep pushing forward despite every sin and failure, I think appeals to certain people on some atavistic level. It’s like an evil superpower.
So, what you think of my attempts to wrap my head around the black swan phenomenon that is trump? Is there more to it than what I can only guess at?