You pick the item and describe as best you can your first exposure to it.
I was trying to remember what it was that I had at a Gondola Pizza place, other than pizza of course, before the place burned down some time in the late 70’s. I think it was gyros, but I’m not sure. Had to be something a pizza joint would have served and something I hadn’t eaten before then. That’s about the right time for gyros for me, so I’ll go with that.
Also, I remember going to a lawn party when I was 6 or 7 and seeing a “hot dog” for the first time.
I think I had my first pizza in the early 50’s, but it may have been even later.
The only venison I ever had was a “deerburger” a buddy fixed for me. I was grown by then.
An apricot. I was maybe six years old, and we had gone to the little produce stand and bought a bunch of different fruit. We were standing in the kitchen, and my father was eating an apricot and suggested I try one. I didn’t want to, but he was very insistent. I took a bite and found it terribly bitter and told him I didn’t like it. He told me that sometimes it takes more than one bite, and that I should try a second bite. I reluctantly did, and this time I really liked it.
Over 40 years later, I can’t eat an apricot without remembering the first time I tried one.
I can’t pin it down to a year, but it was when I was in grammar school when I learned the value of “vinegar pepper sauce” (the kind with banana peppers or other sweet/mild peppers floating in vinegar) for enhancing the taste of turnip greens and collards and the like. Before that time I was partial to spinach (cooked) and hated the other tart and bitter greens. After that pepper sauce discovery I lost my taste for spinach except when it’s fresh and in salads.
Definitely pizza, at Rocky’s Pizza in Webster City, Iowa, 1962 or 63. You smelled the yeast from outside, and when your pizza arrived, you couldn’t wait to take a bite. Ouch.
There was a progression of exposures to salad dressings for me. First was French, which my mother must have either liked a lot, or else it was all she knew about. That was it until I was in high school when I got introduced to Thousand Island. That was it for years until I tried Blue Cheese. After that (it’s still my favorite) I have experimented with Ranch, Honey Mustard, Vinaigrette, and other exotics with ginger and soy and such. But Blue Cheese is still #1.