featherlou, that’s an awesome concept!
Since I’m reading this thread, I may as well contribute an anecdote about this past Xmas. FIL asked Mr. Rilch and myself what we wanted in the way of gifts. I sent him an e-mail listing eight possibles for myself: four books, all best-sellers, none of them expensive; four DVDs, also recent, popular, inexpensive, and all of them available at any Target, Circuit City or other variety store. (I figured I’d get one, maybe two from the list; this was just to give them a range of choices.) Mr. Rilch listed two Playstation games (also not hard to find) and three different brands of cigars (also not expensive, and only naming three for the same reason I named four books and four DVDs).
FIL requested a particular kind of a particular brand of golf balls. We got those for him. His wife* requested a particular kind of a particular brand of video cassettes. No problem; we got those for her.
Christmas Eve, we had our gift exchange.
For Mr. Rilch: A box of handkerchiefs, a package of socks, and three shirts in a style he’d never wear.
For me: A bag full of kitchen utensils. All stuff I either already have, like a pizza cutter and a pancake turner, or stuff I’d never use, like cheap wooden spoons. Four cheap wineglasses wrapped in dish towels (“Part of the gift!” I was told). And a Betty Crocker cookbook, with the CostCo price tag still on.
Not one bloody thing either of us had asked for. But, ha-ha! Mr. Rilch’s “gifts” were converted into a fleece sweatshirt and new sheets. My stuff became utensils I needed and wanted, like a lemon zester and a garlic press**; the cookbook became 1 1/2 of two of the books on my list.
*For other reasons besides this, FIL’s wife is now known as “Jenny the Hutt”.
**I kept the wineglasses and the dish towels. I CAN always use more dish towels, and expendable wineglasses are A Good Thing.