I could have just bought a different Jeep

A semi backed into my Prius earlier this month, so I was going to drive my 1999 Jeep Cherokee. It hasn’t been driven much since I’ve been driving Priuses and Mrs. L.A. started driving more for her nursing job. (She switched to her Tacoma because it got better mileage than the Jeep, and then bought a RAV4 because it got better mileage than the Tacoma and had more room than the Jeep.) I knew the Jeep’s battery needed to be replaced, and it could use a tune-up and oil change. So now I have two vehicles in the shop.

The Jeep got a new battery, a tune-up (the mechanic was surprised it ran at all), new serpentine belt, new valve cover gasket, new oil filter adapter gasket, lube, oil change, cracked exhaust manifold welded, and some other things. $913. After 17 years, some of it in dusty/sandy Southern California and the rest up here where everybody has chipped or cracked windshields, it needed the windshield and wipers replaced. $289.

I drove it to Seattle Wednesday. Seattle traffic is worse than L.A.'s. I had to brake hard at one point, and the Jeep felt funny after that. It was pulling right and not accelerating. I pulled over and my right front brake was smoking. And me without a fire extinguisher. (It didn’t actually catch fire. I called AAA and they said a tow truck would be there in two hours or so. They also said there was a Firestone store two miles away. After the brake cooled, it unlocked itself. I limped to Firestone. Of course I’d cooked the calliper, got the rotor nice and toasty, burned the brake line, blahblahblah. I was 90 miles from home and Firestone was the only game in town. They ended up replacing both front brakes (callipers, rotors, pads, lines, etc.) to the tune of $756. At least the brakes have a lifetime warranty.

So now I’ve spent $1,957 on the Jeep in the past week! :eek: And I still need to have the wheels balanced and get it detailed. And I’d like to get the optional alloy wheels (about $300/set from the Jeep junkyard). The mechanic who did the other work said they sell for $500 to $3,000 (and that he’d buy mine in an instant), and the last time I checked my Jeep might have been worth $2,500. So for what I spent on it this week, I could have just bought someone else’s old Cherokee.

I think I paid about $22,400 for it new. Even though it has about 200 miles short of a quarter of a million miles on it, I’ve tried to keep it in good condition. (Unfortunately, not driving it took its toll.) Had I bought someone else’s old Cherokee, it would probably have some of the same issues mine had. So ‘Ya pays your money and takes your pick.’ I picked repairing the Jeep I’d bought new. In reality, I don’t need the Jeep. I haven’t sold it because it’s been useful enough that the paltry sum these things bring nowadays isn’t worth selling. But we have the RAV4 if we need 4WD. I’ll drive the Jeep a couple/few more years, and then I’m considering driving it down to San Diego and giving it to my sister. It’s a death sentence for it, because they don’t maintain their cars until it’s too late (like I just did!) and they can’t afford expensive repairs. But even with the many miles on it, it will be better than the cars they get and will last them a few years.

As for the Prius, the damage has been repaired and it looks great. Let’s see: New tires, detail, headlight restoration…

I’m in a similar circumstance with my 2000 VW Jetta GLX. I took delivery nearly 17 years ago, when it was brand new. It’s got over 208,000kms on the odometer now. I bought it to replace a Jeep Wrangler that I drove for a few years and hated so very much - just not a truck guy as it turned out.

The VW isn’t worth anything to anyone now, except me. Why? Because despite the years and the miles, I’ve maintained it meticulously and made minimal mods (sport suspension an brakes). Everything, including the electrics and a/c work perfectly on it. The clutch is still original, as is the exhaust. The black leather seats have are still nearly flawless with neither tear nor stitch coming loose. The car is just a joy to drive on every single commute.

I must have spent half it’s original price in maintenance and repairs over the years. I guess most would think that’s a foolish thing to do. But to me, it’s a matter of pride and joy of ownership. This weekend, my son and I are going to replace the plugs and air filters and just have a general spring/summer look around the engine compartment.

My wife wishes I’d get rid of that thing and wonders why I don’t drive my other car more. I tell her I want to keep the mileage low on my other car (because, MB AMG). She just looks at me like I’m insane.

You’re tough on those Priuses. Maybe consider some armor plating?

Let us know if make it to San Diego. Maybe we could organize a mini-Dopefest, or at least go for a beer or something.

Mrs. L.A. says I have bad luck with cars. I’m not tough on the Priuses. It’s all of those other people who run into me. (Except the last one. Two out of three collisions were other people hitting me while I was stopped.)

I’m not a fan of the logic that one should sell an old car if the price of a repair nears the value of the car.

If you junk it and try to buy a replacement, you’re in the “pig in a poke” situation. You don’t know if the “new” car is going to go days or years before requiring something major.

OTOH, you’ve driven your old car for years and have a pretty good idea as to how reliable it is. If it was going pretty good before, then the odds should be pretty good after the repairs. And “pretty good odds” is worth something.

(My current car was “totaled” as determined by the insurance company. We worked with the agent to get the car back + what they were going to pay above its wreck value. Got it fixed for that much. We’re still driving it. 9 years later.)

This is true. With my Jeep, I’ve had a good peek in the poke. It’s only let me down once – cooked the left front brake while towing a heavy trailer. Better to repair it than to replace it. Except…

Except I no longer need it. I’ve got too much invested in it now to sell it, so I may just eventually give it to my sister. My nephew is going to be 17 next month, so maybe I can give it to him in a few years so he can wreck it.

I bought a 90 Cherokee last month for $560 and a 6" Subway sandwich. :smiley:

No, it doesn’t. :stuck_out_tongue:

You did the right thing in repairing your Jeep, Johnny, for scrapping a Jeep other than to part it out is a sin before god.