I had my farm dog killed today

Bear showed up at the farm 9 years ago as a sickly puppy, and kinda hung around and became ours by default. He was always free, would not stand to be tied, and never wanted to come in the house.

There was a wild dog problem on the farm, and he’d kill them when they intruded in a no-nonsense fashion. He’d bark at strangers, and was good with kids and never bit anybody.

He was probably half husky and half german shepherd.

I loved that dog, but I never really liked him, if you can understand such a thing. He was fawningly obsequious when the occasion suited him, but also willfully disobedient when that suited him. He would accept any punishment, and then just do what he wanted to do anyway. You couldn’t trust him.

He was good with kids, but at picnics he would steal hot dogs from little kids like some gentle bully.

“Just put the hotdog down and walk away.” he’d say.

He was hairy and stinky and had bad breathe. If he killed a groundhog he’d usually let it season for a few days before eating it.

Sometimes he’d lay the groundhog out on the porch and reenact the fight for us.

When he talked, he sounded like Joe Pesci.

“Hey, you see that motherfucker? He was right there in our field, can you beleive that? I said “You talking to me, Motherfucker? Are you… Talking… To me?” and then I ripped his fucking leg off, just like this!”
Grrrrrr! Chomp!

And then he’d rip the other leg off the gopher to illustrate his point, and maybe disembowl it for show.

He’d fight them by barking at their face. He’d get really close and just keep barking at them, while they chattered their teeth at him. The goal was to scare them into turning around and running, at which point he’d leap on them, and crush their backs right below their neck.

This is the way he dealt with wild dogs, as well. He always gave the horses a hard time, nipping at their heels. He seemed to be pissed that they were bigger than him.

Though he wasn’t a very big dog, he was a lot bigger than he looked. He had so much hair, he’d float in the pond, and sleep in the middle of the yard during blizzards. I’d shave him in the summer. In fact, I just did so on Monday.

My little girl would ride him and lead him around.

He was a good farm dog.

But, we just moved off the farm, and he wasn’t making the transition well.

He seemed intent and focussed on murdering the neighbor’s nice yellow lab.

The fence wasn’t holding him. He was burrowing under it. We had to keep him tied, or in a crate, or distracted the whole time.

He barked and howled ceaselessly all night. We got a barking collar and that worked for one night, and then he just kept barking and crying and working himself into a frenzy, so I had to take the collar off.

For the first time he threatened me. We put him on medication which had absolutely no effect. He was angry, confused and depressed and getting worse.

We talked to the vet about putting him down, and made the appointment.

I came home to get the dog, and told my wife I couldn’t d it. He was acting like himself again, and my daughter was leading him around.

So I called and cancelled and asked if we could try another medication and give him some more time. They said to bring him in.

The vet told me frankly that he didn’t see the situation improving in a couple of days, weeks, or months. We could keep him permanently tranquilized and confined to a kennel, and see what happened.

He said he’d seen this before and knew where it was going. Bear considered himself Alpha. Not alpha male, Alpha. He thought he was in charge of me, my wife, everybody and would not accept a subordinate position. On the farm this worked out ok, but in a more neighborly area with other people and dogs, and not being completely loose, he was confused frightened and unhappy and all his dominant instincts were coming forward.

It was only a matter of time until he got loose and killed the neighbor’s dog.

Then the vet told me something else. He said, that he was going to get frustrated at not being able to get at that other dog, and look to the next target. The next target wasn’t my border collie. My border collie had already recognized Bear’s alphaness. The next target was me, or more likely my daughter.

I signed the consent form, and it felt like murder. I stayed with him while they shaved his paw and told him he was a good boy. The nurse held his head, and I scratched his ears, and they gave him a full 8cc of barbituate which they calculated would drop a dog of 75 pounds (which Bear was,) like a brick.

They gave him the shot, and just like Bear always was, it was the hard way every time. He fought it hard, but he was still wagging his tail and looking to me for help with trusting eyes as they hit him with another 20ccs and finally he succumbed to the inevitable.

I took him home and buried him beneath a tree as I broke down (as I’m doing now, ) and told him how sorry I was, though he was long beyond hearing. I took him out of the black bag they put him, and gave him a nice grave.

That’s how I killed what has been a true member of my family for the last ten years, a creature that trusted me, tried his best to protect me, and loved me as only a dog can.

That’s what I did to this fine being.

Sorry to hear about your dog, Scylla. I haven’t had a dog in five years. My last one, Oswald, was the best damn dog I ever had. Friendly, playful, and well-behaved. He was part black lab and part chow. Unfortunately, I had to move and I couldn’t take Oswald with me, so I had to give him up. I haven’t been able to get another dog since and it tears me up. One of these days I’m going to get another one.

:frowning:

God, but that’s sad.

And courageous.

Scylla, I could never respect a man that wouldn’t shoot his own dog, when the time comes.

You, I respect.

:frowning:

I know this won’t make you feel better, but in the end, be glad you’re posting here about your guilt and grief at killing your dog, rather than about those feelings over what your dog did to a family member and why couldn’t you have listened to the vet.

I’ve had to make the decision to put down 3 of my pets, and each time it was to get past my selfishness at wanting to keep them around, and to keep them from suffering needlessly. I’m so sorry you were put in a position where you had to do this to keep another member of your family from suffering.

I’m so very sorry.

:frowning:

I’m sorry.

I’m sorry, Scylla. A friend of mine had to make the same difficult choice once. Remember the happy times.

Ouch. I’m very very sorry.
:frowning:

Scylla, I just wanted to tell you something you already know, you did the right thing.

No one can take a chance with their human family. I also live on a farm and see life and death on a regular basis. It can be beautiful or terrible, but you still do the things you must.

You were faced with a crappy situation and you did what a man has to do to take care of his own. Dog and family both.

I’m so sorry for your loss.

You said Bear was really unhappy – it sounds to me like you did what you had to do. It sucks, and it hurts like hell, but at least it was pretty quick and painless for him. And he had you there by his side until the end. Now he gets to go be Alpha in Happy Dog Land – and you have all those good memories in your heart.

I have no idea what to say, except that I admire your strength, and Bear’s. You did what was right.

Oh,I’m so very, very sorry to hear that. You did the right thing, but that doesn’t make it any easier. My sincere sympathy. I’m thinking of you.

Zette

From one dog lover to another …

:frowning:

We could always berate a “cat-person,” to make ourselves feel better …

Scylla,

I’m very sorry for what you had to go through. That really had to be a terribly difficult decision for you to make, and you are a good man for being so strong as to do what was best.

Cassie

Shit, man, that really sucks. :frowning:

But props to you for having had the guts to stand there and watch, rather than dump him on the vet and scram.

Or drop him off at the pound and let him be Somebody Else’s Problem in 10 days when he’s unadoptable (large “free to loving home, needs fenced yard and room to run” Farm Dogs like Bear usually aren’t adoptable).

Or worse, drive him miles out in the country somewhere and abandon him.

In a “no good decision here” situation, and lacking a Dog Adoption Fairy to pop up out of a trap door and take him off your hands, you did the right thing.

:frowning:

I’m sorry for your loss, Scylla. That’s very brave of you to do what you did.

Scylla, I’m so sorry for you :frowning:

I hope it heals soon.

What a sad but interesting story, Scylla. It sounds like you gave this dog a really good lifetime. You did the kindest thing in not keeping him alive as his character deteriorated.

I love the sound of Bear. I hope that you are able to get something to replace him, maybe help another stray or unwanted pup to honour his memory (and call it “Cub” maybe?)

My sympathies. I too, feel you made the right decision. Some animals are simply unsuited to suburban/urban life and it can be very difficult for them to shift gears after a virtual lifetime ( for a dog ) in another setting.

Sadly, very dominant dogs and small children are a potentially tragic mix :(. Especially stressed dominant dogs. You really didn’t have any other options ( since it sounds like he was a poor candidate for adoption ).

  • Tamerlane