Bumping one last time (I promise!). I’ve been peripatetically shopping for a replacement desktop (home use, no real gaming, some HD streaming) that will have the following properties:
Mid-tower or tower (for expandability)
Boots fast (hence an SSD)
16 GB or more of RAM
Relatively Quiet
Supports two monitors
Will last- hence good cooling, no overclocking, etc.
I’ve narrowed my choices down to two distinct systems:
- From Cyber Power- CyberPower Z370 i5 Configurator $1,062
Configuration URL
Case- Corsair Carbide Series Spec-01 (Mid-Tower)
Motherboard- ASUS TUF Z370 PLUS GAMING ATX w/ RGB, USB 3.1, 3 PCIe x16,
3 PCIe x1, 6 SATA3, 2 M.2 SATA/PCIe [Intel Optane Ready]
CPU- Intel® Core™ Processor i5-8500 3.00GHz 9MB Intel Smart Cache
LGA1151 (Coffee Lake)
Memory- 16GB (8GBx2) DDR4/3000MHz Dual Channel Memory (ADATA XPG Z1)
Primary Hard Drive- 500GB WD Blue Series SATA-III 6 Gb/s SSD - Seq R/W: Up to 545/525 MB/s, Rnd R/W up to 100/80k (Single Drive)
Power Supply- 600 Watts - Thermaltake SMART series 600Watts 80 Plus Gold high-efficient Power Supply
CPU Cooling- CyberpowerPC Asetek 550LC 120mm Liquid Cooling CPU Cooler (Single Standard 120MM Fan)
Video Card- GeForce® GT 1030 2GB GDDR5 (Single Card)
CD- ASUS 24X Internal multi DVD-Writer / 24X DVD+R 8X DVD+RW 8X DVD+R
(BLACK COLOR)
OS- Windows 10 Home (64-bit Edition)
Noise Reduction Technology- Power Supply Gasket
- From Microcenter: PowerSpec B665 Desktop Computer $769
Microcenter B665 URL
Case- PowerSpec ATX 28BC (Mid-Tower?)
Motherboard- ASRock H310M-HDV/M.2
CPU- Intel® Core™ Processor Core i5 8400 (2.80GHz) 9MB Intel Smart Cache
LGA1151 (Coffee Lake)
RAM- 16GB DDR4-2400 RAM
Primary Hard Drive- 512GB Solid State Drive
Power Supply- 400 Watts
CPU Cooling- Air Cooling
Video Card- None
CD- ASUS 24x DVDRW Drive - 16x DVD+R DL; 12x DVD-R DL; 24x8x24 DVD+RW; 24x6x16 DVD-RW; 48x32x48 CD-RW
OS- Windows 10 Pro (64-bit Edition)
Noise Reduction Technology- None
Other- Wireless 802.11, Bluetooth, Digital Media Card Reader
The 600W power supply from Cyberpower is on sale as a $0 upgrade from a more modest 450W supply, so no need to comment on the overkill.
I want to thank those who pointed out that a decent sized SSD can be my sole HDD. I was fixated on having at least 1TB, but my current 1TB drive is less than half full (and could be emptier if I did a little spring cleaning).
As I said above, it is not a question of budget. It is a question of getting value for what I buy. There is about 300 bucks difference in price and the only question is whether the additional price gives additional value.
The Cyberpower is probably a bit quieter (but how much quieter). My current PC sometimes sounds like a jet getting ready to take off, so I am sensitive to relative noise.
I will probably keep this PC for at least 5 years and I’m fully aware that the bane of electronics lifetime is heat, so maybe the liquid cooling is worth it. But is it sufficiently better to make a measurable difference in a system I have no plans to overclock?
The Microcenter PC has a few more “amenities” (wireless, bluetooth, a card reader) but are the components all going to be high quality (not a lot of transparency on what brands are being used). Is PowerSpec a builder with a good reputation?
The biggest difference between the two is the video card. On the plus side, no video card means one less board to fail, less heat, probably less noise. On the other hand, will I find miss the video card enough to end up buying one?
I’ve discovered that Microcenter is only about 40minutes in light traffic, so I can order and pick up mid-day sometime this week. Cyberpower has about a three week order-to-delivery schedule, so that’s a negative.
I will make a decision and buy this week. Either click a button or walk in and pick up a box. I genuinely have not decided.