[QUOTE=saoirse]
Why do they need to be purebred? Would you love them less if they weren’t?
[/QUOTE]
Here’s the thing. I love my dog. Madly. In my (not so) humble opinion, he’s the greatest thing on four paws. I knew what I wanted in a dog, and everything I wanted came wrapped up in a Dogo Argentino package. That means personality, character, temperament, health, and appearance. I could get muttley dogs that look similar to a dogo, but there’s no way to know whether or not they’ll have a dogo temperament and I guarantee they won’t have the dogo’s drive.
Getting a dog from the pound is a crapshoot at best. You’ll never get a perfect view of the dog’s personality in the pound because it’s a sick, stressful environment. After adjusting to the new home you may have a completely different dog. Rescues are better but many of the dogs they end up with are abused, abandoned, unsocialized, unhealthy, they might have an unreported bite history, or any number of other things. Many, maybe most, are great dogs… but there’s no way to know that, and I’m not interested in undoing other peoples’ mistakes, or putting myself and my family in the face of the liability of a dog with an unknown background.
I knew what I was getting in my dog from before he was even conceived, and through the breeder’s knowledge and experience I got the particular puppy out of the litter that was perfect for me, my family, and our situation, and like I said, he’s absolutely the perfect dog for us.
So, if you found me a mixed breed dog that is everything my Simon is then no… I wouldn’t love him any less for not being a purebred. But good luck finding it.
Also, if the anti-dog-breeding folks had their way, and purebred dogs were eliminated, we’d eventually end up with something like a Carolina Dog, which is what you get when any number of dogs breeds for any length of time. Ask ten dog folks what their ideal canine companion is and you’ll get ten different answers. If you and me and Catsix walked into a pound looking for a dog, we’d probably choose thre completely different animals. I can’t imagine the world being happy with a single generic default dog for everyone.
I think the problem with this debate is that pound puppy fans will never understand people who are choosy about what they want in a dog. It’s not that I just wanted a canine to live in my house and be my bud, I had very specific ideas about what I wanted. Lots of people do. Some people like big, floppy, drooly, protective, calm dogs. Some people like little, yippy, spunky dogs that need to be prissed over and professionally groomed. Some people don’t care, they just want a dog. Like I said to Catsix, good news is we all have options.