I know someone knows this

Perusing the “What’s in your CD player” thread and I know that someone on the Board can answer this. Geez, put all your collections together and it’d have to encompass everything ever recorded. I’m awed. Totally.

Several years ago my son made a tape for me and I played it to death and then lost it. I’ve asked him what group was on the tape and he can’t remember. (The kid remembers what song was #5 on the Billboard Top 10 from 1976 but he can’t remember to help his mom? Go figure.)

Anyway, in one song, the guy’s responding to a woman who has asked him to tell her what’s on his mind. He’s kinda telling her she really doesn’t want to know, and he talks about someone he killed. But he doesn’t come right out and say it.

The group sounds a little bit like Barenaked Ladies, but I’ve played all my BL and the song’s not one of them.

???

Don’t Go Breaking My Heart – Elton John & Kiki Dee
Dream Weaver – Gary Wright
Love Machine–Pt. 1 – The Miracles
Let Your Love Flow – The Bellamy Brothers
Play That Funky Music – Wild Cherry
Saturday Night – Bay City Rollers
Fooled Around And Fell In Love – Elvin Bishop
I’d Really Love To See You Tonight – England Dan & John Ford Coley
All By Myself – Eric Carmen
Theme From S.W.A.T. – Rhythm Heritage
There’s the track list from the Rhino website

By looking at a blow up view of the cover of the album over on amazon.com, I’m pretty sure the #5 is Theme from SWAT.

Was it a traditional song?

It sounds like a variant of Edward, Child Ballad #13.
http://contemplator.com/child/edwrdbrl.html

If this is the case, it’s not good news, because there are a million versions.

Thanks, Funneefarmer, but what Mike can’t remember is the group that did the song about the guy killing somebody – it was early 90’s – the Top 10 from 1976 was an example of something he probably could remember.

That Top 10 list sure takes me back though – Bay City Rollers! I took my daughter to see them at the Paramount in Seattle. She was 11, I think, had her plaid scarf and all. Sigh.

Thought the balcony was gonna come down with all that rhythmic stomping. And of course I was the oldest person there.

Thanks, Finagle – the melody is really close to the song I’d remember if I weren’t so freaking old.

Does that mean you think it might be a version of Edward? If so, I could think about who might have done it. I know Steeleye Span did a version (which has the
refrain (“for telling lies”).

Does that mean you think it might be a version of Edward? If so, I could think about who might have done it. I know Steeleye Span did a version (which has the
refrain (“for telling lies”).

Finagle – the words don’t match, but the melody does. I’m wondering if whoever did the song borrowed the melody.

Been trying to recall specific lyrics but there’s also a Willie Nelson song in my head called “What Was It You Wanted”, which has a melody similar to the “don’t ask me what you really don’t want to know” song, so I’m getting more confabulated by the second.

Appreciate your suggestions very much!

Not Meat Loaf’s “Anything for Love,” by chance?

Sound like it might be “Indiana Wants Me” by R. Dean Taylor. This site has the lyrics.

Mjollnir and Manduck – nope. But thanks for thinking.

The guy who sang it sounded very much like the lead singer in Barenaked Ladies. And the recording was very spare musically – almost a recitation.

If I could remember even four or five of the exact words rather than the gist, I know you guys’d be on it like flies on, er, like white on rice.