A quick look back on some of the message boards I’ve been on over the years.
Improfanfic - arrogant intolerant close-minded egomaniacs. Some Beatmania IIDX fansite - everyone marches in lockstep, no actual discussion whatsoever (and the only place I ever saw that “distended anus” pic). DDRFreak - anarchy, inmates run the asylum, maybe one person banned ever. GameFAQs - went from well-regulated and courteous to mud-flinging anarchic free for all where no one ever gets banned virtually overnight, absolutely betrayed. Some Samurai Shodown fansite - discussions peter out, some absolute gutter trash piece of crap takes over every discussion and is never restrained in any way; I give an extremely harsh parting blast. Bemanistyle - discussions range from civil to heated, no real help with any of my questions, eventually just lose interest. Codebreaker - No help whatsoever, degenerates into rude denunciations of the very damn device they’re supposed to be assisting with.
And that’s not even counting the ones that I only ever lurked. CNNSI’s boards, in particular, were a cesspool. Good lord, if I never have to see The Notorious KOT blather about “crying towels” again, it’ll be too soon.
And now I realize that of all the message boards I know and have ever known, this is the only one I still post to…AT ALL. Not that this should be much of a surprise. You read the news stories, about how a lot of websites are finally realizing that letting people post whatever they want has been an unmitigated disaster, and now they’re finally regulating the boards, hiring real moderators, keeping a close eye on every thread, cracking down hard on flamers, trolls, and spammers, banning offenders, and removing offensive posts, all things that the SDMB got right from day one.
Subscription fee? That’s nothing. Every other board was completely free to join and use, and in each case I got exactly what I paid for. If a place deserves my money, it’ll get it.
So yeah, Ranchoth, nice sentiment, appreciate it, but nothing we didn’t already know for a long time.