I Pit 'The Onion' and Their Insanely Stupid 'Ask The' Columns".

I’ll see the OP’s one and raise five.

The Onion’s regular features are so unfunny in general that I only read two things regularly: What Do You Think (now called American Voices) and the Infographic.

Oh, look, it’s another “Social Outcast Proclaims Banal Activity to be Newsworthy As If This Has Never Been Parodied Before” article.

Oh, look, it’s another “Thinly Veiled Political Jab at Bush as if You Can’t Get This On Any Other Site” article.

The Onion needs to start hiring better writers and/or just drop the main features. Oh, and it needs to lose the Japanese sex toy ads as well. What the fuck? I don’t want a Japanese schoolgirl-shaped anal plug, and neither does anyone else who shows a modicum of interest on the site.

The only article worth reading in the past 3 years: “Blowjoblessness at all-time high”

Funniest one-liner: “Ask murderer terrorizes African-American neighborhood.”

Speaking of, my personal favorite for years and years:

Ask the Faulknerian Idiot Manchild

followed closely by

Ask a Woman Who May be Poor, But She Still Has Her Pride, and No One Will Ever Take That Away From Her

I found that in the archives yesterday. That was beautifully wrong.

I liked the last two items Sampiro posted. I guess I just think it’s funny when people say “This isn’t funny!”

The pinnacle of the “Ask The” columns was, in fact:

Ask Sir Mix-A-Lot

Well, sure…but JFTR, Esprix is more than three letters, so people can always search that…if they don’t confuse him with matt_mcl, that is.

:wink:

[sub]I wonder if Esprix ever thought about that “can’t search on three letter words” thing? Surely (and I haven’t tried this) putting the full “Ask the Gay Guy” title in quotes would get around that, wouldn’t it?[/sub]

This popped into my mind instantly when I read the OP. I read it when it was new, in 1997. I completely lost it. I thought that because the concept has been beaten to death when I went back I would not find it that funny, but I was wrong. I am a sick, sick woman and it cracks me up completely. It’s all about the language…the descriptions go further and further over the top. “Hot ashes that were once our neighbors fall from the air like a grisly snow!” is a particular favorite. For full appreciation, you need to read it all. I loved it then, I love it today.

Another all-time fave also dates from 97, and is also completely sick and all about the language:

Mother Theresa Sent to Hell in Wacky Afterlife Mixup

A classic!

I hope nobody is ever too old to laugh at “The sizzling, oh God, the sizzling,” “An abomination of science gone awry has brought Hell to our fairgrounds!” and “The roar of flaming gas can’t drown out the tortured cries of the roasted!”

Perhaps he should have titled the thread “interrogate the homosexual fellow.”

And I completely agree with the OP. I don’t even bother to click on the ‘ask the’ articles anymore.

I can’t decide whether my favorite article is ‘Area Homosexual Saves Four in Fire’ (especially the part about how he “collapsed on the lawn, exhausted and gay”) or the Point-Counterpoint (which I can’t find) where a 16 year-old girl goes on and on about how “I will die if we don’t eat dinner soon” and then you scroll down and the counterpoint is an actual starving African kid.

That line stood out for me as well. It’s great. I will somehow work that into everyday conversations.

“Ask the Onion Webmaster who Denies All Access to Mac Explorer Users”

You know, another trick is just to stop reading when it stops being funny to you. A lot of the stuff in The Onion is a brilliant concept that they just take on too long.

To wit: One of the all-time funniest things ever on The Onion is only funny in the headline, but the format made them write a whole article to go with it.

You Want a Piece of Me?
by A Pie

Here’s that point-counterpoint: I Am So Starving vs. I Am So Starving.

I love the point-counterpoints. From My Computer Totally Hates Me! vs. God, Do I Hate That Bitch to European Men Are So Much More Romantic Than American Men vs. American Women Studying In Europe Are Unbelievably Easy, they always rock. But the all-time winner has to be the abortion debate, U.S. Out Of My Uterus! vs. We Must Deploy Troops To Jessica Linden’s Uterus Immediately.

I must respectfully disagree. The all-time winner is We Gave Rex To A Nice Farm Family vs. They Had Me Put To Sleep At The Vet.

“From what I’ve heard, all this happened because I was digging in the plants. Just for the record, it wasn’t me. I do happen to recall a certain member of the household making a racetrack for his Matchbox cars in the philodendrons, though. But what good would it do to name names now? I’m history.”

‘What Do You Think’/‘American Voices’ is one of the few virtually guaranteed laughs I can look forward to in my life. There was one about the economy that had me laughing nearly until I pissed myself, during the lowest time of my life. I forget the question exactly, but one person (I think the Indian guy) said “I was just laid off from Baskin Robbins. That may not be a bellwether of the economy, but it’s a bellwhether of me dipping my wang in the butterscotch.”

Man, that is one belligerent pie.

OMG, does anyone remember this one? Romantic Comedy Behavior Gets Real-Life Man Arrested

I can’t find it online, but my favorite was always the point/counterpoint between a humidifier and a dehumidifier. Can’t go wrong with the classics.

I also liked the appreciation article for everybody’s supportive gay friend Blaine. (It’s a salute to the Hollywood asexual homo hero cliche.)

You are both wrong. The title belongs to It Was Then That I Carried You vs. Bullshit, Jesus, Those Are Obviously My Footprints.

Another vote in favor of the OP. I usually get a chuckle from the headline, but after that why bother reading the article? I’ve heard the joke.

Anyway, my absolute favorite point-counterpoints were Ooh, Mr. Smarty-Smart Is Talking! By Jeffrey Tyler, Second-Grade vs. I Was Told I Would Be Debating Former National Security Advisor Brent Scowcroft By Martin McKinnon, Director, Hastings Center For Foreign Policy Analysis,

followed by

I Want To Be A Fireman, By Kimberly Meier vs I Want To Be A Seven-Year-Old-Girl, By Tom Gibson, Fireman

And you know, I miss T. Herman Zweibel. There, I’ve said it.