Friend Across Town told me an anecdote this evening at which I am still laughing. We were sharing stories about family members not listening to us. Like when I asked my mom, more than once, to “hang on to that case of New Coke when you move, because I actually like it!” Three months later when I turned up at their new digs, I inquired after the New Coke and was informed, “I threw it away. You said you didn’t like it!” Or when Friend asked his mom to get green olives with pimentos for his graduation party. All of a sudden, she’s insisting that he loves black olives. After about five repetitions of his telling her he has always preferred pimento olives and has never even had a black olive, she concedes, “Well, if you want to try pimento olives, I can get a jar…” (No, the party was not going to succeed or fail on the strength of the olive selection. But jeez, where was she all those years when he was snacking on pimento olives?)
But the capper was the following. Friend will be referred to as Jeff; his brother as Mutt. They are 12 (brother) and 14 (Friend), in what was known at the time as a “record store”.
“Jeff” was and is a collector of pre-rock music. He found a single of a song called “If You Don’t Know Me By Now” by Harold Melvin and the Blue Notes, and grabbed it up.
Mutt: Why you getting that?
Jeff: I’ve been looking for it for a long time.
Mutt: Yeah, but why are you buying it?
Jeff: Huh?
Mutt: We have a copy at the house.
Jeff: We do?!
Mutt: Yeah! I’ll show you when we get home.
Jeff: You’re sure now.
Mutt: Positive.
Jeff: Well, I think I know our record collection pretty well, but okay.
Mutt: No, for sure we have it. Wait till we get home.
Jeff: Must be one of mom’s that she keeps in that carrying case…
At home, Mutt flips through the record rack, supposedly in search of “If You Don’t Know Me By Now” by Harold Melvin and the Blue Notes. “Aha!” Triumphantly, he pulls out a copy of…
…“Last Night I Didn’t Get To Sleep At All” by the Fifth Dimension.
WTFF?!
After I stopped laughing and picked myself up off the floor, I asked Jeff if the two records perhaps had a similar label. No such thing, he assured me. Totally different labels, both in appearance and the corporate sense. Different groups, different eras, and the titles don’t have even one word in common! Jeff says he still has no idea, beyond the fact that his brother is a moron (scientifically proven in other situations), how he could have been so utterly mistaken. Happy ending, though: he went back to the shop and the record was still there. Oh, and their mom made Mutt apologize.
I swear, if I ever hear that Fifth Dimension song again, I will rupture myself laughing. (Not much chance that I’ll hear the Blue Notes song, or recognize it if I do.)