I only started following this case for real a day or so before closing arguments, and right now the jury is deliberating. While that’s happening I thought it would be interesting to think about what would have happened if things went slightly different that night. This is a different question/discussion that the actual trial thread, which I did read at least some of (it’s long).
I watched the footage and read accounts of what seemed to have happened. I’m not asking what should/shouldn’t have happened, but what if:
- 2 of the people killed seemed to be going for Rittenhouse’s rifle and got shot a split second before or during the scuffle. What if either of them had actually got a good 2-handed grip? The rifle was tethered to Rittenhouse so I don’t think it could have been yanked clear away from him… but the chances of getting shot would go way down (compared to standing several feet away from the shooter) if someone is fighting for control of the gun.
Even if they couldn’t take the gun completely away, it would have bought time and let other people rush in and join the struggle. Has there ever been a time when someone was armed, got swarmed by people, and then lost control of the gun? What happens or would happen? Is the gun man always brutally beaten? Is it realistic to think that the crowd might just sit on the kid until the cops show up?