Flashback
Only fair to pit myself I suppose, as in this one, I don’t look very good.
I was 30 and living at home again temporarily (supposed to be) when she learned I was gay. This was a few weeks after learning I was gay, after the “suicide attempt” where she left a letter on my boyfriend’s door asking me to come home to see her one last time and to please bring her some Rolaids, and signed it “Love Mama” so I’d know who it was from (for in those days there were no shortage of suicide grocery lists).
I started to slap her when she said the above but stopped my hand in the air. In stead I told her to apologize. She absolutely refused.
“Fine. I’ll grand your wish.” and I left her house.
What I meant was ‘so far as our relationship goes, I am dead to you, you’re history, shalom’. She thought I meant that I was going to kill myself. She panicked and over the course of the rest of the night she drove over two counties desperately trying to find me, the only place she didn’t check being the place where I was, which was at a friend’s house- an address she didn’t know about. She banged on my boyfriend’s door but he wasn’t home (neither was he with me) and his roommate told me she was the most frantic person he’d ever seen. "Man- it was like she was trying to get somebody to help her pull her baby out of a well or something, kept saying how she had to make it right and she couldn’t live with what she’d done.
I went home after he told me about that, but there’s no causal relationship. I went home because I needed clothes and my cash. When I got there it was noon the next day and she was sitting in her chair even though it was a work day. She didn’t say anything but she hugged me, not crying, not showing any real emotion. When she let me go I went into my room and packed a bag. She came into the room and said, softly, “I really wish you wouldn’t go. You know my house will always be your home.”
“I do not live where I am wished dead. I do not eat at the table with people who say they wish I was dead. I do not share anything but a world with people who say they wish I was dead. But thank you for the offer.”
“I did not say I wished you were dead.”
“No you didn’t, I’ll grant you that. You said you would RATHER see me dead than gay.”
“You’re not gay.”
“I assure you. I am.”
“I don’t want you dead. You know that.”
“Then apologize for saying it.”
“I didn’t say it.”
“Then apologize for what you did say.”
“No.”
“Why not?”
“Because… it’s my house and I’ll choose what I apologize for.”
“Then choose to apologize for what you said.”
“No! Don’t make me apologize for what I never said!”
“THEN APOLOGIZE FOR WHAT YOU DID SAY AND STOP SPLITTING HAIRS!”
“You’re planning to go to graduate school at the end of this year.”
“Yes.”
“If you leave I’ll need to find a roommate. I need to put as much as I can in my IRA and I can’t do that if I have to pay full rent. You’ll have to find an apartment for the next year and you can’t afford to live alone and you’ve never had good luck with roommates. Stay here as a roommate. It is a matter of practicality.”
“Where I can pay half the rent, half the utilities, and be wished dead.”
“I won’t wish you dead. I never said I wished you were dead.”
“You said as good as.”
“Think about it.”
To my eternal chagrin, I ultimately took her up on her offer. I really couldn’t afford my own apartment, she really did need to put as much as possible into her IRA, and I really have had the most miserable experiences with roommates, and my whole reason for being there then was that car repair and other expenses had left me broke. So I remained, but it was not a happy time.
I spoke to her as little as I had to, I did not share meals with her, and I tried to be somewhere she wasn’t at all times when we were both awake and off work. Essentially I slept there. I would not host a party with her (which I had done a few times) and so she never had one again. We were more or less civil to each other, with minor flare-ups, but it was not the same relationship. I had spent my life bestowing glamour on her, doing all I could to make her seem and feel more than she was. I corked the bottle and put it back on its shelf, if she wanted self-esteem or laughter in her life then I wasn’t going to take it from her or do anything to keep her from getting it, but neither was I going to bestow it. I was tired of being Atlas to her ego and self-image and she could find someone else.
She fell one day getting out of the van she drove at work, freak accident. Her employer was very good, paid all expenses (it was OJI but not really anybody’s fault), but she developed blood poisoning and needed constant care. So I did not go to graduate school that year but went the next instead so I could remain with her as caregiver. To my credit, and for some odd reason ego compels me to say, that I never expressed resentment over this, she was my mother, it was my duty. And I loved her. I still told her I loved her. But upon occasion I also told her I wanted to hear an apology for something she said in July 1997. The answer, depending on how the question was phrased, was always either ‘I never said that’ or ‘No’.
The glamour embargo continued. She was a bitter 63 year old woman of no extraordinary accomplishments and I absolutely refused, for the first time in my life, to do anything whatever to make her feel like she was anything else but a bitter 63 year old woman of no extraordinary accomplishments. I had not seen her this miserable since we were broke. I hated it. I hated myself for not doing more to make her laugh, to make her happy, to build her up again, “Madame is the greatest former lady wrestler of them all”, to take something moderately funny she had said or done and retell it in such a way that it was not only hysterical but she believed she’d said or done it that way and was truly a character for having done so, or reminding her of something truly remarkable she had said or done when she needed to be reminded of it, or exposing her to new things that she’d enjoy (she had a major sweet tooth and it was fun finding things like Tiramisu that she’d never had but loved. I even found myself browsing grocer’s aisles and starting to instinctively buy that interesting looking thing with the pineapples, or instinctively thinking “Oh, Mama’s gonna LOVE this story” when something funny happened at work, or instinctively want to say “What’s wrong” when she was obviously upset and somehow make her see how great she was. But-
I couldn’t. I wish that weren’t the case, but I couldn’t.
Unless she apologized.
And she wouldn’t.
One night we were watching a documentary on the making of the musical Ragtime on PBS. She was mainly doing her crossword puzzles and not really paying much attention, but when Marin Mazzie, a truly beautiful voice, sang (in its entirety) We Can Never Go Back to Before, she looked up and paid attention. She was visibly affected by the line
Back in the days
when we spoke in civilized voices…
and had a tear in her eye after
back in the days
when everything seemed so much clearer.
women in white
who knew what their lives held in store.
where are they now,
those women who stared from the mirror?
we can never go back to before.
We went outside to smoke later the same evening and out of the blue she said (it had nothing to do with the conversation of that evening- repeated here as a paraphrase of course) “I just want you to know that I never… I want you to know that I want you to be happy. Even if I don’t agree with everything you do. I love you more than life. Which isn’t saying much, but I love you more than I’ve ever loved anything, anyone. I don’t ever want to not have you in my life. When you go away… I want you to know that I’ll miss you and that you’re taking my world with you.”
That is your choice, I told her. Your world should be with you.
“I’m proud of you. I want you to know that when I hear other people complain about their children, all the things they’ve put them through, I think, my son never did that. He was always a joy to be around. It was when I wasn’t with him when I was miserable. I am so proud of you. What happiness I have is from you.”
I told her that I loved her very much and I was proud of her. I also told her that I needed to hear an apology for saying she wished I was dead. She told me “There are things you’ve never apologized for…”
“Like what?”
"Things that were hurtful… that… "
“Name something.”
“It’s not important. It’s… I have fought with depression and anger my entire life”
“And they have won hands down. May I have an apology please?”
“No. Whatever it is you want an apology for I probably meant at the time I said it and it would be hypocritical.”
“Fine. We’ll have to leave it at that, I suppose. But please don’t ever think I’ve forgotten.”
“If you ever forgot something that offended you I’d go to St. Margaret’s Hospital and demand to know what the fuck they did with my real baby.”
As much for my benefit as for hers I uncorked the glamour. Things returned to normal, that being relative, and she was happy again, at least as happy as she ever was. I kept her laughing and feeling she was very special, and in some ways she was, at least to me, until I went to grad school, and then I was constantly back home again doing likewise.
She was in ICU most of the summer my first year and once again I was nurse. She had horrible gashes from an emergency surgery- a lathryscopy had failed and her gall bladder had to be quickly removed the old fashioned way and gangrene had set in and she had to have other surgeries. I spent the summer as her home healthcare giver doing some rather hands on stuff- packing wounds, taking care of some serious needs, and hearing the words no son ever wants to hear, no matter how heartfelt they are, from either of his parents-
Please don’t tape over my anus- that idiot nurse assistant did in the hospital once and it wasn’t comfortable.
I put as much of a positive spin on it as I could and again went to extremes not to make her feel like it was an imposition, because as anybody who’s been caregiver knows it is and it isn’t. But I think being there and taping those wounds is some serious karma points.
So I graduated some months later and a job was available locally in my field, good pay, a college I had graduated from, and one of my co-workers was a professor I particularly liked (though we’d only met via TV- it was a distance course). I considered applying for it- and my mother, all for the idea, made the comment “And you can stay here, save your money- it’ll work out great!”
“Well, I’ll probably get my own place eventually.”
“Well it’s an option but you’re welcome to stay here indefinitely of course…”
“Yeah, but some privacy is in order…”
“Why?”
“If I should have friends over.”
“Are you ashamed of me?”
“You know better than that.”
“Well… oh. I’d rather hoped you’d gotten that phase out of your system.”
“It’s not a phase. At least if it is it’s been going on since LBJ and this is either Bush or Gore, however they decide.”
“It doesn’t need to be discussed.”
“But if I get that job I think you’d agree, I should get another apartment.”
“If you’re going to be having spend the night visitors then I’d prefer you get it in another city.”
“Fine.”
“You choose fags over me, in other words.”
“I choose non-ultimatums over ultimatums from people who I should think I have proved my loyalty to sufficiently not to receive ultimatums from. But then I would have thought that I would never hear said-same person say they wished I was dead.”
“And you didn’t.”
“Or words to that effect— ‘rather you were dead’, I know. But what I never heard was ‘I am sorry I said that’ or even that you revoke it with apologies.”
“And you never will.”
“So you would still rather see me dead?”
“I will not answer that question. Because I do not have to. You know the answer.”
“Then be redundant. Would you still rather I be dead?”
“I will not be hauled to Canossa in my old age and forced to recant something that I just honestly can’t imagine you have any doubts about especially in my own goddamned house!”
“Fair enough. This is your house, you can make any rule you like. And that is why I will never live in this house, I will never live in this city, rather than cause you inordinate embarassment.”
“Fine!”
And so I did not ever live in the same city she lived in again. She kept me well informed of jobs in the city- amazing how someone who has no connections in the library field and doesn’t surf the Internet somehow knew when there was any kind of public, academic, special or other library job available, but I refused to live in her city. I visited her constantly- too constantly most would argue- I was in almost daily contact with her, but I kept my bargain. And during one of our few major arguments in the last few years she accused me of refusing to move back to Montgomery strictly to spite her or because I was embarassed of her. I answered her
“My refusal to move back to Montgomery is because you never apologized for a remark about my being dead that I need to hear an apology for. It’s a need Mama. I know that you’re sorry for it, I really do, but I need to hear you apologize and specifically say that you did not mean it. If they offered me a $500,000 directorship of the brand new $500 million ALABAMA LIBRARYOPOLIS tonight, I would not take it until I heard you apologize for that sentence.”
“Then I guess that means in two years you’d be out a million dollars because you’re not going to hear it. It’s been too long and I think the whole thing is ridiculous.”
“Fair enough.”
I never returned to Montgomery. I turned down a job at Auburn University 45 minutes away when she made a comment about how she always knew I’d be back. Ironically, that one she did apologize for, but by then I’d turned it down and frankly, as I told her truthfully (though I don’t think she realized I was being honest) I didn’t want the job in the first place. When her health started failing I took a position I suppose I did swallow some pride as I took a position I really didn’t want in Tuscaloosa because it was 100 miles/90 minutes away rather than 250 miles/4 hours away as the job I actually liked was, but it was an effective compromise.
As horrible as it sounds, when she became terminally ill I was still considering not moving back to Montgomery, but I’m glad to say that I swallowed my pride and did. I was going to be her primary caregiver and live in her house at last, something she’d wanted and lobbied for since she bought the place. Ironically, her death from a blood clot (or kidney failure or lung cancer or pleurisy or whatever exactly you want to blame it on- it was all of the above and I think kidneys and some long word I looked up but can’t remember were dual causes of death on the certificate) a week or two before she came home derailed the plan, so since her death, in a moment of supreme irony that my father would have loved, I live in her house, but she ain’t heah.
The point is that I have issues with women in my family saying that they wished I was dead. Or, technically, phrases that involve my being dead and their preference to see me as such to a gay alternative. And my sister enacted those issues.
But I love her.
And more to the point I want the equity in this house.
To be concluded.
(And I warned you this one didn’t make me look good, now didn’t I? But in interest of fairness I should like Heinrich IV stand in the snow myself for a post.)