Straight female here.
I’m not emotional, I don’t like talking about emotions or having deep heart-to-hearts about feelings. I despise indirect communication, especially of the “stereotypical female” type. The only reason I didn’t have a hard time in high school is because I had a best friend who was very similar and we just avoided the rest of the girls except when necessary.
I don’t do emotional excess (screaming fits, crying jags, etc.) and I get very uncomfortable about people who do.
I can’t stand passive aggressive people.
I like to ride motorcycles.
I love computer games and have been puttering with computers since the mid-70s (my dad’s a nerd, and I picked up his nerd-genes).
I don’t like babies, toddlers, small children, or pretty much anything to do with them. I don’t like talking about them, interacting with them, or otherwise acknowledging their existence unless forced.
I don’t like romance novels, celebrity gossip rags, or anything similar. I can’t figure out why anyone could possibly care less that Overexposed Celebrity A is sleeping with Overexposed Celebrity B, who’s having a baby, or who looks fat this year.
I don’t like girly clothes at all. I don’t own a dress or skirt (though I do have a Utilikilt) and feel like I’m in drag if ever forced to wear one. Ditto any kind of girly shoes (especially high heels).
I like snakes and lizards, though I don’t care for bugs (spiders in particular).
Up until about a year ago I played ice hockey.
I hate small talk, though I love having long substantive discussions, particularly late at night.
Though I have a high degree of emotional empathy (I can usually tell how someone feels about me, and am good about picking up subtle cues about people’s moods and adjusting accordingly) I don’t have a nurturing bone in my body when it comes to humans. That doesn’t mean I won’t happily bring you soup and give you a foot rub if you’re my spouse and you’re sick–it just means that I don’t get my sense of worth by taking care of other people.
When I get money, I spend it on gadgets, electronic goodies, books, computer games, musical instruments, and similar.
I’m competitive and if something matters to me I want to be the best at it. If I don’t have a reasonable shot at being at the top if I work hard, I tend to lose interest.
I don’t wear makeup, nail polish, girly jewelry, or any other feminine adornments.
I love fast sexy cars–but I want to drive it, not ride around in the passenger seat.
Seriously, sometimes I think I’m a gay guy in a girl suit. Although, that said:
I go to pieces over cute kittens, and get very upset when animals (especially cats) are hurt.
I have way too many shoes (even though they’re all boots and athletic shoes and other similar things).
I don’t like sports (can tolerate football and hockey, but even those bore me if I have to watch them too long) and can’t stand “sports news” type shows.
Politics bore me.
I don’t like to drink, and can’t stand the taste of beer or wine.
I’m not good with spacial relationships (I do terribly on those tests where you have to fold things up in your mind and say which shape they make, and I can’t tell north from south if you spot me a compass most of the time).
I’m not great at putting things together. I can do it if forced, but I’m happy to let the spouse do that since he’s better at it than I am.
I’m a good counselor (I often think I missed my calling) and can usually get to the heart of friends’ problems after talking to them for a bit and offer them nonjudgmental advice or insights.
That’s about as stereotypically girly as I get, though.