Well, to start with: scum (especially scum who has played this game) is very very likely to sell out a fellow scum at the beginning of the game. So: the case you make to defend me is actually a fallacy (if we take the role reveals at face value, of course).
Well, it would be unfair, but who knows? Maybe it’s still winnable.
And as for two, he said roles would be revealed…just not which roles.
There has been a bit of argument on the spoiler boards as to the points you may or may not have earned from the jerkface bonus in this post. Some say you didn’t call us out individually, but other say you did call both of us out in a creative fashion. I agree with the latter camp.
36 points to you!
Nice work.
Obviously they use claymores, for they were sharks drawing on their Scottish ethnicity. They’ve abandoned the kilts though. Too much drag in the water.
I think it really, really reeks of scummitude for you to reject what to me seems like a pretty obvious tip-off that there’s something hinky with the role reveals. Now, I assume that since the mods said it was a playable game that it’s somewhat balanced - maybe the scum also have a handicap - but if I were scum in this game I’d be throwing up smoke screens on the mod action too. Like you are. I think you’re acting like you know something we don’t. And I think you don’t want to role claim because in case you don’t get lynched you are not going to want to nail yourself down like that. I think you stink to high heaven of anti-Town actions and I am not going to let you FOS me for not voting for somebody who might not even be scum.
That would have been pretty clever of me, considering I voted him for a specific slip and then retracted that vote before anyone else voted for him because no one else who spoke up to that point thought it was a slip.
I don’t think it is obvious that there’s a problem with the role reveals. My earlier post gives my reasons.
Yeah, that’s why I think you’re probably town. As I said earlier.
It’s looking pretty likely I’m getting lynched now. Would someone like to articulate the “strong” case against me? I’d just be interested to know before I go.
Well, I think your insistence that the roles are what they say they are (Maha=scum, and his defenders are also scum) is bad playing. We know we’re in a gastard set up plus with Nanook…why are you so insistent on that?
I also think that you played with very little commital, just trying to squeak by without really making waves, which is how scum often plays. You haven’t really done anything to try to encourage discussion. You’ve just floated, in my opinion. I posted my analysis which you obviously disagreed with.
Will you at least agree to tell us what you genuinely are right before you die?
That’d be nice. But I don’t see him cooperating too much from now on.
Vote ColdPhoenix
Current vote count:
ColdPhoenix (4): Zeriel, Freudian Slit, Zsofia, DiggitCamara
Freudian Slit (1): ColdPhoenix
Not Voting: BillMC
As of now ColdPhoenix will by lynched at Dusk.
He’s not going to role claim, because he’s scum and he thinks keeping the setup obscured will help his side.
Well with the numbers against him, I would have expected a claim.
But since he hasn’t, may as well make it unanimous
vote coldphoenix
Current vote count:
ColdPhoenix (5): Zeriel, Freudian Slit, Zsofia, DiggitCamara, BillMC
Freudian Slit (1): ColdPhoenix
As of now ColdPhoenix will by lynched at Dusk.
I have always planned to honestly claim, just as I have always told the truth in this thread.
I didn’t answer the questions on whether I would claim in case a statement that I would honestly claim would encourage my lynch to get information. Obviously that strategy didn’t work very well. 
I truly believe that my theories on who is likely scum and not are true, hopefully people will remember them after my lynch and role reveal.
If things stay as they are I’ll be claiming before the day’s out.
I obviously have a lot to learn about this game! 
If you think your claim will change opinion, then it is better to claim sooner rather than later, and give folks the opportunity to evaluate your claim. Too many times have folk claimed at the last minute, and still get lynched coz folk aren’t around to change their vote.
Agreed. I’d rather see a role claim now than later.
I’d prefer town to win than scum, so I was trying to catch them with my post **Mahaloth **analysis.
I know I killed Normal Phase and TexCat, but I also killed Mahaloth so I wasn’t all bad! Heck, what am I saying, I’d have killed you all if I’d the chance!!!
Mwahahahahahah!
My name’s ColdPhoenix, and I’m a Seriel Killer.
Enjoy the rest of the game.
And being good scottish sharks they had nothing on under their kilts
This is odd to say the least.
Were Nanook and CP lied to vis a vis being SKs? Is one of them in fact an SK? Are they both? Are there more?
That is, Nanook’s “reveal” was that he was a Town Doctor. Was he given the SK role in PM but in actuality he was really town? Or is he actually an SK and is the reveal a lie?
I’m assuming you, CP, got the SK PM. I’m just wondering if you’ll come up Town and if you do come up Town, what that even means.