Ok, I talked to my friend again, and asked him particularly about what I mentioned immediately above: for the last 2/3rds of this thread, it was “staff” versus “command” that I was (latterly) confused about.
[Before continuing, I’d like to thank Bear_Nenno, not for the first time, for his off-line personal interest and help.]
He was in-country from 1965-74, and was promoted to Master Gunnery Sergeant in 1969.
Points I gathered from him–I post them here for general interest–after I read him most of this thread. (I skipped the Terminator 2 sidebar.)
- A lot of discussion depends greatly on peace or war-time operations.
- People called him “Gunny” all the time. He didn’t like to be called “Top,” which (as you probably know, but I didn’t) was for anybody higher in rank, as a general (heh) thing.
- As to the “staff” vs. “command” roles which interested me: ie, who advises in a tent in an FOB, and who is in the field with an assault, or whatever. (Again, I’m summarizing what impressed me as new information, and I very well might still have interpreted him, or the facts, wrongly):
He talked about the general role of an NCO, who maybe knew much more about the field situation and men–and comparable situations in the past from his own experience–than a Lt. fresh out of West Point. The way he put it was: ok, when he’ sin the tent talking to an officer, he’s a “staff.” When they send his ass out, he’s “command.” So it’s fluid.
I asked him if everybody got sent out, and that’s when he mentioned a) war vs. peace time, where most everybody went into the field; b) some Master Gunnery Sgts. have to stay in “staff” roles even stateside “to get shit done.” c) aside from that, even in a FOB, “a few” MGS’s “had their head up the Colonel’s ass” and managed never to be in a position to be shot at.
Finally, back to a question I had in OP: if any sort of demonstration of weapons facility and knowledge figured in promotion to his rank (you know, with “gunnery” in it). His answer was quite moving, actually, I thought.
He said that the Captain or whoever, signed and stamped your promotion without particularly giving a fuck about anything at all you demonstrated about weapons–if you survived long enough to be recommended for promotion, it was pretty obvious you could handle about anything.
Thanks to all for this thread.