Exactly. We need to define Christmas Movie I guess. For example the movie Holiday Inn (with Fred Astaire and Bing Crosby) is technically not a Christmas Movie other than singing “I’m dreaming of a white Christmas” one time. But it is a Christmas movie, just like “Die Hard” is because it takes place during Christmas Season; When I think about it, I also think of Christmas; so I think it IS a Christmas Movie and I voted that it wasn’t; until I thought about it for a while.
So my definition of a Christmas movie is simply: “Does that movie evoke thought of Christmas to me?” Yes. Yes it does.
It’s a Wonderful Life
A Christmas Carol
National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation *
Die Hard
Die Hard 2
[sub]The only time I ever heard my grandma belly laugh was during this movie. Before that, I didn’t think she was capable[/sub]
When my husband was very sick, the last Christmas we had, I had some weird fantasy evening planned of watching Christmas movies. So before I left for work, I told him “Get us some Christmas movies for tonite.”
And on Christmas Ever we watched Die Hard & Die Hard II.
I honestly thought we were completely unique in this. Until I saw this thread. Nice memory.
It’s a Wonderful Life is a Christmas movie because it has that Christmas schmaltz. Jingle All the Way has that as well, plus it is about Christmas shopping and references a Christmas song* in its title.
*And, yes, I know that “Jingle Bells” is arguably a not Christmas song. But it is a song about the joys of winter, and Christmas is ultimately a holiday designed to make winter more enjoyable. And so are the above movies.