In the recent thread on Israel after one person denied that anti-Semitism was a problem in France and claimed the idea that it was was “American propoganda”, I noted that polls showed that 45% of all French citizens thought it was “probably true” that “French Jews are more loyal to Israel than to France” and that 35% of all French citizens thought that “Jews have too much power in the business world”.
Now, to me these are obviously anti-Semitic statement reflecting centuries old canards which led to the pogroms and to the Holocaust, but at least two commentators on the thread argued that this wasn’t anti-Semitic.
One in fact fervently argued that the second example was merely “a stereotype” that no one should care about and very strongly implied that Jews should “stop behaving like paranoid freaks” because “some people were killed nearly a hundred years ago.” He also argued that French Jews shouldn’t be surprised about being viewed as being more loyal to Israel because they were “foreigners” even though they’d been living in France since before the establishment of the US.
Now, I’m not attacking the people who disagree, but I thought I’d open it to the rest of the Dope and see if they agree that people believing that “French Jews are more loyal to Israel than to France” and that “Jews have too much power in the business world” are anti-Semitic statements or if they should be seen as merely “stereotypes” that one shouldn’t care about.
Obviously, I think those ideas, along with the idea that Jews are “foreigners” are disgustingly anti-Semitic and led to both the pogroms and the Holocaust but that hardly means I think the situation for Jews in France is remotely comparable to that of Jews in the modern day Arab World, 1930s Germany, or even Jews under the Soviet Union or that Jews in France need fear persecution.
Similarly, I don’t think Muslim Americans and African-Americans need fear persecution but that hardly means that racism isn’t an issue in the US.
However, I know some may disagree, so I thought I’d let other members of the dope chime in on whether they think such statements along with the idea that French Jews living in France since before the invention of the printing press are “foreigners” is “anti-Semitic”.