[QUOTE=Blake]
[QUOTE=InvisibleWombat]
Go back and read the paragraph you were responding to and tell me what part of it doesn’t hold water. Everything I said in that paragraph is 100% verifiable fact.
[/QUOTE]
It doesn’t hold water.
There isn’t enough nitrogen (fertilizer) naturally occurring that could feed the plants that feed people and which feed live stock.
[/QUOTE]
Obviously, I need to say this again: Go back and read the paragraph you were responding to. After doing that, pull out one single solitary fact that you can refute with cites. And while you’re at it, read about the nitrogen cycle.
[QUOTE=Blake]
The additional fact that YOU can produce enough nitrogen via crop roation to make money for yourself doesn’t in any way invalidate that point.
[/QUOTE]
That was my point. I didn’t say squat about whether there’s enough naturally-occurring nitrogen for the entire world. I didn’t say “organic is good.” I said only that I can use crop rotation to grow alfalfa, beans, and corn without adding any nitrogen fertilizer to my fields. That statement, despite your protestations, is 100% true.
[QUOTE=Blake]
You do realise that if our yields of food were halved that woudl result in something like 80% of the world’s population starving to death, right?
[/QUOTE]
I’d like to see a cite for that, Blake. First, show me how decreasing yields of crops by 50% would decrease our production of fish, free-range cattle, and other non-crop foods. Then, show me how decreasing those yields in developed countries would affect the production of crops in countries that currently use little or no artificial fertilizer. Then, when you’re done translating that crop yield into an overall percentage reduction in food, you can provide me a citation that demonstrates how 80% of the world starves to death. I know, I’m being facetious here. I don’t expect you to actually research an answer.
[QUOTE=Blake]
No, your statement is funny. His point is perfectly sound.
[/QUOTE]
Sheesh, Blake. Stop trying to read between the lines and put words in my mouth. Read exactly what Philster said, and exactly how I responded. I specifically said that the assertion, “Organic = bad for the environement” is silly. Plants have been growing without manmade fertilizer and pesticide since long before humans came on the scene, and the environment somehow survived it. If you translate his statement into “organic farming, when done poorly and to excess by millions of humans, can have detrimental effects on the specific land that’s being overstressed,” I would agree with him completely. But that’s not what he said.
[QUOTE=Blake]
Philster’s point is perfectly sound. If the world went organic tommorow it would be an environemtal catastrophe unparralleled in human history.
[/QUOTE]
Please quote back to me the place where I proposed the entire world going organic. For that matter, please show me where I disagreed with the first paragraph of Philster’s post #17 (I disagreed with one specific sentence, which I still maintain is a silly overgeneralization). If you’re going to argue with me, at least have the courtesy to only argue things that I actually said.
[QUOTE=Blake]
This entire thread is discussing organic farming, not organic chemistry. When Phislter said “Organic = bad for the environement” you knew damn well that he was talking about organic farming, not organic chemistry.
For you to suddenly pretend that we were talking about organic chemistry or organic somehting-other-than-farming is disingenuous in the extreme.
[/QUOTE]
Don’t accuse me of being disingenuous, O great twister of words. First of all, I never said squat about organic chemistry. Not my field. Secondly, I never pretended we were talking about anything except what was actually stated in specific posts, which I’ve quoted to you (if you’d bother to read them). Third, this thread title says organic food, not organic farming. The cattle from my ranch carry an organic label just like the corn from someone else’s farm.
[QUOTE=Excalibre]
When the plant produces the pesticides, you can’t wash them off.
[/QUOTE]
I certainly don’t claim to be an expert in genetic engineering, but I thought you could make plants resistant to pests by means other than turning them into little pesticide factories. Can’t they be made less attractive to various pests, or better able to withstand the ravages of various natural plant diseases, molds, and so forth?
[QUOTE=Excalibre]
I’m not an expert on this stuff, so I wouldn’t claim to know the answers. But I’m skeptical that organic agriculture is necessarily that much better for humans or the environment. It would take real answers to some of these questions to convince me.
[/QUOTE]
I sit on squarely on the fence as to whether organic farming is a good or bad thing. I personally believe that organic beef tastes better, and I can attest that it’s been very easy for me to produce. I have few enough cows that I can grow everything I need to feed them on my own property. It’s also been profitable, because I don’t spend any more money doing it. My operation, however, is a very small one, and I don’t depend on it for a living. I know organic doesn’t scale well.
I just can’t buy into the rabid “non-organic is poison” argument, nor into the equally rabid “organic is stupid/harmful/whatever” argument. Clearly, organic farming and ranching has both advantages and disadvantages, and I generally ignore both sets of extremists.