Is Spirit of Eden by Talk Talk the greatest album ever made?

I’m really surprised that almost nobody aside from musicians seem to be aware of who Talk Talk are. Their entire catalog is excellent, but their last three albums are especially amazing.

Spirit of Eden is generally considered the very best of their work. Personally I think it’s even better than Pink Floyd’s Dark Side of the Moon.

I know that since post-rock has become mainstream in this decade that you hear more praise for Talk Talk. Do you think in 10-20 years time they will be mentioned in the same breath as Pink Floyd, Radiohead, Velvet Underground, the Beach Boys and Beatles? I really think they are just as good if not more amazing than any of those bands, and they hugely influenced not only post-rock but also Trip Hop, emo and shoegaze music. Not to mention a lot of vocalists like Lights, Gwen Stefani, Bjork, Hayley Williams, etc I’ve always thought there was something “feminine”, though not effeminate, about Mark Hollis’ voice and his songs are otherwise more fit for female singers.

I think “Inheritance” is probably my favorite track:

Music threads are best suited to Cafe Society. I will relocate this one.

Oh I’m sorry. :smiley: Anyway, you should listen to the album if you haven’t, it’s amazing!

I remember them as “The Reaction”. A tune from 1977…

More pub rock than punk, a good band though.

No, it isn’t. It’s not even as good as it’s predecessor, The Colour of Spring.

I’ve written a bit on this board about Talk Talk (and Mark Hollis (and Tim Friese-Greene), and I agree that they made some amazing music together.

I’m with Bo, it’s not even the greatest Talk Talk album (although I’m more an It’s My Life than Colour of Spring fan - Such A Shame is one of my all-time favourite songs - isn’t that car crash opening the best thing ever?)

And everyone knows* Unknown Pleasures* is the greatest album ever made :wink:

[QUOTE=protoboard]
Is Spirit of Eden by Talk Talk the greatest album ever made?
[/QUOTE]
I’m going to go out on a limb and say “No.”

I remember when I was young enough to believe that my personal preferences reflected some universal truth.

Who? What?

Exactly.

I love it when I read something that exactly expresses my own philosophical opinion, but had been unable to find the right words to voice the thought.

Wow, some people on this board sure are smug. :dubious: I was just asking a question.

BTW, the idea that the Beatles or Pink Floyd are the best is also subjective. Not to say I don’t love em because I do.

No. Vocalese by The Manhattan Transfer is.

No, no. The answer is the tried-and-true Pet Sounds, of course. :slight_smile: Althpugh the more I listen to, the more I think Refused’s The Shape of Punk to Come needs to enter consideration for me. Right now, it’s Pet Sounds and Loveless that are one and two, but the Refused album has over time made it into my top 5.

I’ve maintained for nearly 2 decades now (and written on these boards for half that time) that that is the greatest rock album ever; it’s even better than The Clash’s Combat Rock.

You should have made this a poll. That would have been fun.

Yeah, listening to it today, it still sounds fresh and forward-thinking. I first heard it probably c. 2002, a good four years after it was released. Too bad punk didn’t actually go in that direction. :frowning: (As for the Clash, the obvious London Calling is my favorite, and in my top ten all-time. I could never quite get into Combat Rock. Perhaps it’s time to revisit it.)

I’ll have to check that out. I don’t recall the name, did they ever tour the UK back in the day?

Every word of this is correct.

They were no Shriekback.