Is the Law of Attraction true?

In one word, no.

There is no evidence that by merely thinking of the result you want that the universe is going to bend and bring that result to you.

That being said, there is a psychological factor where, if you concentrate on the result you want you’re more apt to do the things yourself that will being about that result. But that’s just psychology in action; there’s no magic involved and there’s no scientific “law of attraction.”

If you sit on your ass and wish for things, the Universe is under no compulsion at all to provide them to you. If you define your goals and** take actions **to fulfill them, you will achive many of the things you seek.

This is not a “Law of Attraction.” This is a “Law of Economics.” Good things come to those who work hard and never give up. It may appear to a lazy person that good things just happen to some “favoured” people but aside from the statistically insignificant outlier or Kardashian, all successful people work hard to achieve their success. (This does not mean that they then do not slide on the ice for the rest of thier lives.)

It’s complete and utter bullshit. People who believe in it are very gullible, and easy to market to. Of course the marketing people are gonna push this “law” as hard as they can.

I looked at the second example and got this running through my head. Thanks a lot.

People pick up on cues from others. What you put out will influence what you get back and what you expect from a encounter will determine what you put out.

One’s life long patters tend to repeat till we change ourselves. It is usually very evident in relationships, where we tend to fall into the same pattern that fails time and time again.

Larger then that, on a universal scale well perhaps it would require beings such as angels who watch over us and help us, they may also respond to what we put out.

This is wrong and I can prove it.

  1. Everyone who enters a lottery dreams of winning it. The vast majority lose money.

  2. I have never used the ‘law of attraction’.
    I retired aged 55, owning my own house. I have a great group of friends and decent health. :cool:

Of course I achieved these things by my own efforts, not by some woo nonsense.

At my first job interview (immediately after my leaving University , the company interviewers asked if I had any questions. “Yes” I replied “What is the company pension plan like?”
It was a superb plan (e.g. index-linked rising payments; lump sum included) and now I live off it comfortably. :slight_smile:

Similarly with my other achievements (save for a deposit; be pleasant to people; exercise and eat right etc.)

I simply want evidence to believe in stuff.
I believe in gravity.
I believe there are likely to be aliens somewhere in the universe (just not that they have visited us.)

If you don’t look at the evidence, you’ll waste a lot of your time and money. :smack:

Despite many, many years of thinking about them far too often, such ladies as Olivia Newton-John, Geena Davis, or (more recently) Kristin Chenoweth, Stana Katic, and Kari Byron have never been drawn to my presence. Hence, the Law of Attraction is bogus. :slight_smile:

Typo. It was $500K per year.

See what the Law of Attraction gets you!?

I was absolutely horsecrazy when I was a girl. I lived and breathed and dreamed horses. I read horse books, made elaborate plans about what sort of horses I wanted, I had model horses, and I made tack for those model horses out of kraft paper (which I carefully crumpled and smoothed out so it resembled leather) and brass wire (I made buckles that were less than a quarter inch long). If the law of attraction worked, I would have been surrounded by horses.

I didn’t need the law of attraction. I needed money to get horses.

Well, an awful lot of copies of The Secret were sold. You’d think the # of billionaires would have increased exponentially since then.
Or, further proof it’s bullshit:
if positives attract, and like attracts like, what happens when you try to touch the positive poles of two magnets together?

If it sounds too easy, it is.

I forgot to mention in my previous post, the meditation thing I haven’t checked into yet. The water crystal experiment I don’t know if another has tried to test water like that yet. So while it isn’t necessarily certain for me yet, it does make me wonder.

http://www.lifencanvas.com/2012/09/the-water-crystals-experiment.html

While I found them negative, at very least what you can say is that positive worded water turned into crystals

What would you accept as evidence that it doesn’t work?

I appreciate this answer,it coming from one who says he achieved what he wanted. My question though is are you sure you didn’t use the LOA to get it? The LOA frormula is ask, believe, receive. Also focusing on what you want, coming from the place of already having it (like having the same feeling). Are you sure you didn’t do this at all? Even praying to God or “if someone is out there” once about what you were trying to acquire? Are you sure you weren’t coming from the place of already feeling like it was yours?

Viola! Here I am - not hot, not Asian, married and 50. Maybe your thinker is broke.

But at least you’re musical.

I’m not sure, that which is a clear counterexample WOULD do it, but that person might not know if he is really using it or not. Like, maybe someone put in a lot of effort, but maybe they were of the frequency of doing hard labor for success and its not a real example of it not existing. Or the person is lying, OR don’t realise they were on some level using the law and not knowing. With that said I don’t know what would show me it is real or not.

And maybe a counterexample wouldn’t do it if it’s not a law but you can use it in a lot of cases and it would work, but not always required

Um, no. At the very least I could say that Mr. Emoto takes nice pictures of ice crystals from bottles that he says had sayings taped to them. At this point I know nothing about how many pictures he takes to get nice ones.

So, nothing really? Why ask questions like this if you can reason away any response that don’t fit your thinking? What do you want from this thread?

You went about it the wrong way. You should have found some evil your parents did you (like make you move to California) and demand misery compensation.
Worked for my daughter. :smiley: