Isn't all of the objection to AI just straight-up Luddite-ism and "normal growing pains" for a new technology?

Right; he’s the richest man in the world (depending on how you measure it, I know it’s complicated) because he’s not satisfied with being merely a billionaire but negotiates for ever bigger equity pay offs. He doesn’t seem to me to be the type who will ultimately give up some wealth to make the world better.

Well the other thing billionaires can do is liquidate some of their wealth.

So even if it’s true that money in the bank is useless in a world where people just care about food, guns etc…people with money can buy that shit prior to money being worthless. In most apocalypse scenarios they will have time, if they haven’t already.

In overnight apocalypse scenarios, yeah, they might well be screwed, but we all would be.

Yes, when I mentioned that billionaires like Musk have proposed something akin to a universal basic income to offset AI potentially taking away all the high-earning jobs, I cited reasons why it wouldn’t work. another one of which kind of goes without saying-- it’s not credible that people like Musk would willingly give away money; it’s just hand-wavey answers to give to people who ask them “what happens when AI takes all of our good jobs?”.

But what I wonder is, putting apocalypse scenarios aside to stick more with the premise of this thread, let’s say that AI is eventually so successful at taking high-skill, high-paying jobs away from humans that we end up with 90+% of the population living at or close to poverty level, scrabbling to make ends meet since they can’t find work that pays a living wage, and less than 10% of an elite management class headed up by billionaires, taking most of the wealth generated by AI.

How would that work, economically? Billionaires only exist, and continue to be billionaires, because they’ve convinced a lot of people with some money to hand over a portion of it to them. If most of the population is broke, wouldn’t the gravy train also eventually run out for the billionaires?

If you assume wealth is a zero-sum game then they don’t have to worry about the gravy train because they already have all the gravy, and the train, and the tracks. They can keep enough of the luxury economy going to satisfy their needs despite what’s happening to the rest of society.

You could argue we already have that scenario. Compare the USA to all of Africa, or all of the third world. We exist and they exist relatively independently of one another. The only difference with the billionaires is that they are sort of living among us, but even then not really. They can just build bigger walls around their palatial estates, fly in their personal helicopters or jets to get where they need to go rather than rely on public roads. Build their own power and water and sewer plants. They can hole up in Florida or New York City or London and keep those places mostly functional even while the surrounding cities/counties/countries crumble.

FYI, the term “The Ukraine” has been officially obsolete for 35 years now and is viewed by Ukraine and Ukrainians as a pejorative term of Russian propaganda.

The “the”, when rendered in a Slavic language, means that the place referred to is a mere region of a bigger country, not a country of its own.

Calling it “The Ukraine” amounts to saying it’s properly a vassal state or internal territory of Mother Russia.

I hope you don’t mean that.

Can you explain this? My understanding is that neither Russian nor Ukrainian have definite articles, so I don’t understand how this is possible. If it’s a rule in English (rather than Slavic), I’m not familiar with it: we seem to have no problem with The Netherlands or The Gambia.

Except that would be an incorrect assumption. Wealth is not a zero sum game.

People aren’t poor because Elon Musk is a trillionaire.

Look, everyone is all terrified that they are going to lose their very important, very fulfilling job of building management reports, creating spreadsheets, middle managing, drawing logos for corporations, or whatever version of sitting in an office or at home getting paid a lot in exchange for participating in the administrata of Corporate America. Meanwhile most Americans seem like they are either too broke or too constantly pressed for time to actually enjoy life.

I think that’s the wrong way of looking at it.

If someone invented a magic box that could produce more of what society needs at a fraction of the cost, would such a society suddenly become “poor” because most people wouldn’t have “jobs” to do anymore?

The trick is that it will probably require restructuring society in some new way and people often don’t like that.

Both can be true at once: the society as a whole doesn’t become poorer per se, but the magic box can change the distribution of wealth and jobs, sometimes by a lot, often quicker than individual people, families, and industries can adapt.

It wouldn’t be as big a problem if we had support systems that helped people through these sorts of transitions, but we often don’t, and it just kinda sucks for people who fall through the cracks and suddenly plummet a few classes without any ladder back up.

But if Elon Musk were to spend $8 billion by giving $5 to every person in Africa, that would have a negligible effect on Musk and an enormous effect on Africa.

Replying to myself: Ukraine or the Ukraine: Why do some country names have 'the'? - BBC News quotes the scholar Anatoly Liberman, whom I know slightly, as saying that English speakers must have started using “the” because they were aware of the etymological meaning of Ukraine. This is nonsense; I suspect we dropped the “the” for the same reason we’re no longer saying “Kiev”: we want to adjust our language to a more pro-Ukraine stance, and these small changes are a way to signal it. End hijack.

There are lots of good points in this thread. One thing I’d like to highlight is the mistaken belief that LLMs are currently doing most things better than the professionals. I have seen no evidence they are doing a better job than trained professionals. They are doing a worse job, at an incredibly fast rate of speed. Any sector that adapts general LLMs is probably doing a marked trade-off when it comes to industry knowledge and quality of work. Making that trade-off in only a single sector will result in problems, but it seems we’re prepared to make that trade-off in almost every sector imaginable, in technology and medicine and education and art and every facet of our personal lives.

It reminds me of a sign my parents had in the office of their small business:

Need a fast, cheap job? Won’t be good.

Need a good, cheap job? Won’t be fast.

Need a fast, good job? Won’t be cheap.

It’s pretty obvious the AI market is gunning for the first option.

Humans have an overwhelming tendency toward conservation of energy and that includes the amount of mental effort they are willing to spend on things. Brains are just as lazy as bodies. Convenience is always a trade-off for something. Our lives bear little resemblance to those of our hardy ancestors, who toiled endlessly because they had to. Every convenience that has worked its way into cultural norms has come with a trade-off. We’re all dying of metabolic illnesses because of convenience food and having every sedentary entertainment option at our fingertips at all times. I remember recently I was thinking about getting a tiny snowblower to clear snow off my car, but ultimately I decided against it. It’s probably good to experience inconvenience, to at least have choice points where we aren’t willing to make the trade off. There’s no reason I can’t scrape off my own damned car.

And the same is true of how we think. There is no question that the invention of the printing press changed how people processed and retained information. Skills were lost, and undoubtedly new ones were gained. The problem I have with general LLMs is people’s brains are instinctively, naturally wanting to offload cognitive demand but there is no evidence of cognitive skills gained in return. We have no idea what the long-term impact of cognitive offloading at this scale is going to be. Surely humans have a long and storied history of cognitively offloading certain skill sets, but there aren’t any examples I can think of where we did this globally, across many domains at once. And initial research on how this is affecting people’s ability to learn is not promising.

If you already know how to do hard cognitive labor I shouldn’t have to convince you how important it is. But my concern is for subsequent generations who have no idea how important that labor is. For people who seem to think the point of writing a novel is to have a finished product and avoid the labor, not understanding the labor is the point. Struggling and striving and wanting to give up and regrouping and persevering and finally turning out an imperfect but meaningful product is the stuff humanity is made of. It’s how we’ve built everything we’ve ever achieved.

I’m not sure humanity is ready to make that trade-off.

Easy there Sally Struthers. What enormous effect do you imagine that would be? At best that’s like a week’s salary at the average African minimum wage.

So what does everyone do next week?

maybe $5 billion might be better spent on things like roads and powerplants that have multiplying effects in the economy?

$5 per head regularly for a long time would have a huge effect.

$5 given once would simply disappear like pouring a canteen of water into the Sahara. A month later there’d be almost no evidence it had ever occured.

One other issue with AI: I’ve noticed in the last year that my workload has increased dramatically. I don’t use AI, but people use it to write to me, and now I have more and longer things that need to be read and responded to. People spent next to no time creating them, and they’re not that good, but they’ve added hours to my week.

Economic stimulus: freeing up the money to move a bit. But it’s obviously impossible in practical terms, anyway, so it doesn’t really matter what would or wouldn’t happen.

I guess the next generations probably wouldn’t see it as a trade-off, just the way things have always been. It’ll be a mystery to them how people ever had to think for themselves without constantly relying k on the hive mind.

In my field, I often see this dealt with by mass AI triage of incoming mass AI slop. Have your robot convince my robot that a human should read it, otherwise just let them chat for a bit and come to some sort of agreement. That, or if it looks like absolutely zero human effort was put in, I just hit the spam button.

I don’t know if that is a viable system in your role / industry…

The two major categories I see are:

  1. journal articles for a peer-reviewed journal. It doesn’t take long to realize it’s a “no,” but it does take a few minutes, plus correspondence & record-keeping.

  2. emails from students. What used to be two sentences is now several paragraphs.

In both cases, people are pretending that they are NOT using AI.

Students also submit AI papers, though this is not allowed, and it’s easier to just give it a bad mark on its content than argue back and forth about whether the student actually wrote it, and file the appropriate report.

Mere money, especially a paltry sum like that, will do jack for Africa.

If Elon took that $8 billion and bought, say, bicycles to donate, that would have a much greater impact. he could buy nearly 45 million rugged, region-suited bikes with that amount of money. And the effect of bicycles in rural Africa is immense.

I’m not sure why people are objecting so hard to my scenario. The point was that he could really make a difference across a big chunk of territory & human beings without feeling the cost. I don’t care whether it’s fictional bicycles or fictional five-dollar bills or fictional iphones.

Because $5 is not “really making a difference” . Your initial example looked like a joke.

More realistically, he’d probably just offer them free Grokbot accounts and half a hyperloop, then call them all pedophiles when they say it won’t help.