[QUOTE=furt]
Taste in food, like art, is all a matter of opinion. If someone likes hamburgers, only a snob or an elitist would say that he is wrong, incorrect or deficient to prefer a Quarter Pounder to a fancy meal prepared by the world’s greatest chef. It’s all just opinion.
[/QUOTE]
I agree with you both technically and in spirit, most of the time: folks who show disdain for those who don’t share their tastes generally piss me off, and what you say seems self-evident to me.
However, I do believe that you often have to learn to appreciate certain fields of aesthetics.
For example: when I was twenty, I couldn’t stand beer. I’d had homemade beers, I’d had Coors, I’d had small artisan microbreweries. At best they tasted to me like seltzer; at worst they tasted like goat urine*. In college, however, I decided to learn to like beer, and over the course of a couple of years I steadfastly tried drinking different beers even though all I could taste was an overwhelming, repulsive bitterness in them.
And I found a beer I liked (Widmer’s hefeweizen). ANd then I found another beer I liked (Killian Red). And then more and more and more beers that I could like; and soon, that overwhelming, repulsive bitterness transformed itself into a variety of pleasant hoppy notes in beer that I could taste along with other lovely flavors. Having learned to recognize and contextualize the strongest flavor, I was able to appreciate it, differentiate subtleties in it, and, most importantly, taste other flavors beyond it.
I think the same thing can happen in other fields. Right now, most classical jazz all sounds alike to me. I can’t tell my Marsalis from my Ellington, and to be perfectly honest, they both bore me to tears. They both sound exactly the same to me. I am virtually certain, however, that if I decided to dedicate some serious time to learning their music, I’d learn to contextualize the overwhelmingly jazzy “flavor” of their music, and I’d be able to differentiate between their styles and appreciate subtleties in what they do.
There’s a chance I’d dislike their music even after I learned it. But my experience with learning new aesthetics has consistently been that it’s very rewarding.
So there’s a way I disagree, perhaps, with a possible implication of the OP. Taste is subjective, yes. But someone who’s spent awhile studying a particular aesthetic can be objectively more knowledgeable about that aesthetic than someone who’s treated it with contempt, and so the person who’s studied it may be objectively more qualified to offer an opinion on an example of that aesthetic. I’m more qualified to offer an opinion on whether a particular IPA is tasty than is my mother-in-law, who never drinks alcohol; I’m not nearly as qualified to offer an opinion on a jazz album as is my wife’s ex-boyfriend, who plays in a jazz ensemble.
Daniel
- To whoever’s the first to say “You know what goat urine tastes like?!”: HAW HAW HAW! Extra haws if you say it specifically because of this footnote.