For a number of years, a controversy has been raging in genealogical circles over the practice of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints of posthumous baptism. I am concerned for purposes of this discussion, in particular, with the practice of posthumous baptism of Jewish Holocaust victims, which has the Jewish genealogical community mightily pissed off.
Now I have only the most superficial knowledge of the tenets of LDS, in spite of a required Illinois high school state history curriculum unit on the Mormon history of Illinois, and I am well aware of the enormous contributions the Church has made to genealogical study; its vast research facilities are made available free of charge to users of all faiths (and I’ve used them myself). However, though I am not a religious person (my interest in Jewish genealogy is because I am interested in the history of my family, and well, my family is Jewish), I am all about free will, as long as a person’s exercise of free will does not infringe on the free will of others.
So as my family hails from parts of Europe quite thoroughly ravaged by WWII (Latvia, Ukraine, Poland, Belarus, and maybe a couple of others), and my maternal grandmother’s family in particular hails from a small town no more than a couple hours’ train ride from Auschwitz, chances are pretty darn good that I lost numerous extended family members in the Holocaust.
Apparently the theory behind LDS posthumous baptism is that all people, regardless of whether they were born before the foundation of LDS, should have the opportunity to enter Heaven.
Now I may not be religious, but I respect the fact that my ancestors likely were. Surrounded as they were by various flavors of Christians, I imagine there was no shortage of chances to be baptized, and perhaps some of my ancestors even had to resist forcible attempts at baptism.
If they didn’t accept Jesus as their saviour, it probably wasn’t for lack of opportunity. And in fact, many of them likely died for their refusal to declare belief in Jesus. So it offends my sense of respect for free will to baptize them now that they have no choice in the matter. After all, Jews don’t proselytize, so why not give Jews the same respect?
Am I missing something here?