That doesn’t have anything to do with deserving. And I understand she’s upset, but I’m kind of wondering what she expected was going to happen to the guy. Odds were he was either going to end up dead or in jail again.
The phone goes without saying. Unfortunately, a call to the police does not make them magically appear so I’d still need something to defend myself. I could throw the phone but I don’t think that would hold them off for long.
Granted that I’m not a DA or detective and don’t have all the evidence, but this looks to me like the most cut-and-dried self defense case I’ve seen. Even if Maryland did have a duty to retreat, I think it’s hard to argue that it’s reasonable to retreat from someone within sword’s reach of you.
And it’s not at all unreasonable that the kid might have had a real weapon, not just a decorative wall piece. On the one hand, I and a few friends of mine have had weapon swords since high school (mine’s European-style, but one of his is a katana), and on the other hand, I also have a pair of decorative Japanese swords, and they’d be more effective still in their sheath and used as a club (albeit a crude one-- You’d be better off with a table leg or baseball bat). If I tried to use one of those decorative swords to sever a wrist, I’m pretty sure the blade would fail before the bone would.
And if I were ever in such a situation, I’d go for one of the hiking staves near my door before any of my swords, but that’s just me.
There is no place in my house where I am more than 7 feet from a weapon. What I would grab would strictly depend on where the miscreant was ingressing my domicile. If he’s lucky, he will merely get thrashed with an oosik.
Agreed.
I am beginning to subscribe to the theory of calling the cops from behind a closed door with a firearm at the ready than actively going after the miscreant, though.
Of course, if he tries to swipe my C Band 4DTV receiver, it’s a whole 'nother ball game.
I think that the miscreant could reasonably (and I use the term loosely) expect to suffer the penalty described by law and not something more. Personally, I would consider being killed as a possible penalty for breaking into many 'Doper homes, but I’ve probably given a bit more thought (ten seconds or so) to it that your average B&E guy.
My guess about the wounds is that the kid swung the sword at the oncoming bad guy baseball bat style. Bad guy seeing the swinging object approaching, puts his hand up to block. The student, not being an actual samurai (that we know of) doesn’t compensate with additional swing strength and on the follow through slices the chest open.
I predict no charges, and an uptick in sword sales.
Well, being in a ninth-floor apartment, there’s realistically only one point of entry to my home. And I’m more proficient with staff than any sort of sword, too.
runner, I lovingly polish my oosik at every opportunity. I actually have daydreamed of using it to beat down some B&E scumbag, and then getting to listen in court as the description of the encounter is read into the record and the term gets defined. I invision much laughter from the court, and a terminally embarrassed thug.
I actually have in addition to a number of antique 15th and 16th century weapons, a Del Tinlongsword that I had bought for my SCA champion back in the late 90s [he has left the SCA and he gave it back so I could give it to a new champion] I would really not want to get hit by it as it is a functional and reasonably edged sword.
I personally would be grabbing my sidearm as a gimp I can’t retreat or close for attack.