Judging vs Condoning vs Interpretation....Another Christian Debate

Well, 'Sprix, her argument is based on three assumptions that are not proven by Scripture, though I’m pretty confident she’ll quote off verses that prove it in her mind:

  1. God was concerned about the actual sex act itself, not about the reasons why someone might do it. (Unlike His normal view about sex as recorded in Scripture.)

  2. God is of the opinion that only one man and one woman may licitly marry each other. (This is disproven abundantly by most of the Old Testament, but whatever…)

  3. Sex is sinful whenever committed outside marriage, regardless of whether marriage is a legal option and regardless of whether there is a loving commitment between the sex partners.

It all reminds me of the time that someone proved to me from Scripture that God approved of capitalism and frowned on communism of any sort, carefully avoiding the end of the second chapter of Acts in the process.

Hey, in addition to creating God (or our idea of him) in our own image, we also create His Law as a divine rubberstamp on our own cultural mores.

I don’t know if it’s a God ordained marriage, but I assume it would be a legal marriage. There’s no damage to me that I know of, just my concern for that person.

Originally posted by Polycarp

I’d hoped she would expand a bit more on how she sees you as dealing appropriately with your sexuality – but I certainly cannot fault her answer.

Let me give some background information on how we became so close. I’ve known Golden Boy for years since he was in grade school. Then I heard he was homosexual which at the time he was so young I took that with a grain of salt, and didn’t pay much attention to it. Well as time went on he confirmed he was homosexual, which I still didn’t pay any attention to it. When the kids all started high school and being kids they needed somewhere to hang out (as none of them had their license) slumber parties abounded. The girls were allowed to stay all night but boys had to leave I wouldn’t let them stay all night. So one night I was asked if any boys could stay over night at a slumber party and I said the only one that would be able to stay would be Golden Boy. That statement got me in trouble, the straight boys told me I was discriminating against them, thus the beginning of a beautiful, loving relationship to all the kids who have stayed here and hashed out their hurts, angers,test scores, their loves, etc.
Poly I really don’t see Golden Boy as having any serious problems in dealing with his sexuality, he is very secure in what he is, not flaunty, he’s very mannerly and actually very handsome. Maybe it’s because we all accepted him and encouraged him not to degrade himself, but to have self-respect. Which is something I’ve always tried to instill in all the kids that come around me. Being around him is a joy, and being around all the kids at one time is a blast. It’s comical to listen to them. I’ve gone cruising with these kids, and have heard Golden Boy say “boy he sure looks hot” and in the next sentence heard the girls say “you can’t have him I’m gonna get him” it’s really hard to explain the relationship we have because a lot of people cannot imagine all of us being together and having a good time. Don’t get me wrong because we are a mixed group of sorts, some of the girls have boyfriends, some are looking for boyfriends, Golden Boy sometimes has a boyfriend, sometimes he doesn’t. Me I’m married with kids of all kinds. There is one thing I can say about all these kids, they have all graduated now, and are in college, and I expect they will all excel in whatever profession they choose and expect them all to look at people as we have with Golden Boy, with respect.

And I still do not know if I answered your question fully, but I gave it my best shot.
If I didn’t answer your question fully it could be because through some good guidance from above we have something that the world over wishes they could obtain, a beautiful loving caring relationship with fond memories for everyone to back upon…:smiley:

In other words, H4E, you think they’re engaging in acts prohibited by God. Thanks for almost clearing that up, what with all the obfuscation.

That was absolutely beautiful. I hope Sugar Belle, Golden Boy, and the rest of “your kids” realize how lucky they are to have you in their lives. :slight_smile:

OK, Lib, even I think this is obscure.

Tris

Sorry, Monty…I hope Polycarp answered your question. It is a bit hard for ME to do so, since we don’t HAVE a “duly constituted church court.” I guess the closest thing would be if someone were to be asked to speak with the pastor and church elders concerning something…but as far as I know that hasn’t happened in our church. If it ever DOES happen, it is kept confidential and I haven’t heard about it. Which, come to think of it, is entirely possible.

What I was referring to was the instruction from Jesus concerning “judging” each other in the attempt to help each other live our faith more fully and expressively. I would expect that this would be more of a private matter…“You know, Cheri, I don’t know if you are aware of this, but you appear to be sitting in judgement on people…and I wonder if we could talk about it? Here are some Scriptures that I feel might help you to understand what I mean.” And Cheri then has been instructed, by Christ, to listen to her brother/sister in Christ and study those Scriptures, pray about it and then determine if she needs to work on that area of her life.

Does that clarify my understanding of the matter?

All right, then. I’ll reprint it.


Actually, I think the statement that “I love the sinner, but I hate the sin,” is a lying bunch of self serving crap. I don’t know who is fooled by it, but it certainly isn’t God.

I don’t hate my sins. I like my sins. If I didn’t like my sins, I wouldn’t be sinning! I could give up paying taxes without a qualm. I could forgo the dreaded sin of eating coconut cream pie easily. I hate coconut cream pie. You see, when someone talks about hating sins, it’s your sins they are talking about. Now, those, they hate.

And why the hell are they thinking about your sins, anyway? This preoccupation with the sins of others is transparent self righteousness. I’m sick and tired of people telling me about the dreaded evil of someone else’s transgressions against the love of God. What about you, asshole? Are you so fucking perfect? Fall on your knees, and cry out for mercy, you slimy piece of shit. Tell me about your trip to hell, why don’t you?

And what really pisses me off is when they try to blame their sniveling tattletale version of love on God. You guys piss me off so bad; I start up on my favorite sins of all. Bitching out the bible thumping poltroons who are stealing my religion. Why don’t you call yourself Hellists? That’s all you care about anyway.

Now you know why I don’t get into these debates as much as I used to. I am gonna get myself banned this way.

Tris


One of the most beautiful and important posts I’ve ever seen on any message board anywhere.

One thing I’ve noticed about judging, especially from what I’ve seen in the past few months, is it tends to put the person doing the judging in a position of moral superiority. It can sound like that person’s saying “Look how wrong you are and how right I am.” I think that’s one thing that’s gotten His4Ever in trouble around here, because even though I’m sure she doesn’t mean the second half of that statement, the implication is there unless the person doing the judging does or says something to contradict this. It may also be why it’s easier to accept judgement from people you know well than from complete strangers. You know your friends well enough to know whether or not they think they’re perfect; the same can’t be said of relative strangers.

I’ll throw out another example from my own life, if you don’t mind. A few years ago, I was particularly impressed by an essay someone at my church wrote which was included in a Lenten devotional my church distributed. Knowing how much I like compliments, I called him to compliment him on what he wrote. He took this opportunity to give me a half hour rundown of my faults. Now, this fellow is old enough to be my father, and I’m sure he meant it in a loving, paternal manner, but I still thought it was completely uncalled for. Who was he to place himself in a morally superior position to me? I should add, I suppose, that he seems to think of himself as a sort of elder of the church, and he may have thought he did have moral authority over me.

As I think I’ve said, we all judge, and there are situations when we’re called to act in a judgemental fashion. One thing we need to be aware of, though, is that we will be judged even while we’re judging. I’m sure the fellow on the bus I mentioned earlier had the same “Who is she to judge me?” reaction I had to my would-be church elder. As much as I try to justify my actions, he has a point and I accept the consequences.

CJ

To clear up any possible confusion, my statement on legal marriages was my opinion of what His4ever would think.

Myself, I think any marriage is legal which is performed by any civil servant(my marriage was at the courthouse and it felt just as solemn as any church).

Whether God sees it as legal is not any of my business.
Yes, I think same sex people should be allowed to marry.

We now take you back to the original thread, now in progress.

Very well said, cj.

I agree with you CJ. I’ve advised His4ever more than once to follow-up “I believe that the Bible says homosexuality is a sin” with “but I also believe that it says my own sins are equally as bad”.

She never responded.

Count me in there. You see, jjrt is dalovindj’s aunt and SugarBelle is my cousin. I count myself lucky to have them as relatives. From time to time on this board I have mentioned my southern family and here they are. It is good to see them here making the aquaintence of these personalities that I have grown to know and respect.

It is partly because of them that I am so constantly thinking about and debating theological issues. I have had to reconcile my suspicions that religion is all just myth and faith is no more than ignorance dressed up in fancy words, with the utter faith of my family. This family has always been good to me, shown me nothing but love, and with sincerity and passion tried to tell me of the God they have found. The love that they show forces me to at least consider their positions, since I do not feel they would knowingly lie to me.

We have always discussed religion. Discussion turns to debate, and then debate turns to argument. They have the same genes as me, so you can imagine how damn stubborn they can be. Over the Christmas break (no matter how much of a city slicker I become I make sure to make it back at least once a year to enjoy that southern hospitality) I recommended this board as a place where we could discuss these things without really being able to raise our voices due to the rules of conduct here in GD. I must say, I find jjrt’s explanations of her faith much more palatable in this form.

Background aside, re the OP, I must say that I really can’t stand those religious folks who constantly warn of impending hellfire and the doom that sins will bring. These brimstone preachers seem to be taking the place of judge themselves, even when their own book says such is not their place. I can’t stand it when, in a similar vein, people swear that they know their god is the one true one. What justifies this certainty? What makes them so sure that their god would or would not behave in a certain way? As this board illustrates, their are thousands and thousands of interpretations of the one book “The Bible”. Ranging from belief in a twisted I’m-a-gonna-burn-millions-of-people-for-eternity type of god (which I would never worship even if it did exist - the sick bastard), to belief in a I-love-everybody-no-matter-what god (sounds nice - but then again so do Unicorns). Given all these interpretations, how could anyone honestly expect me to believe they have the REAL straight dope on the issue?

People have their beliefs and I can accept and respect that. It is when those beliefs include demeaning and ridiculing other people that I have a problem. When one person tells me they are more spiritually pure then another it seems to me that they are using their religion to gratify their ego. Such a position tells us nothing about reality, or a creator, but alot about the prejudices and character of the speaker, from where I am standing anyway.

I hope that the compassion and acceptance that jjrt has shown here is really the truth in her heart. While I still suspect her faith is based in myth and what she wishes were true, any road that leads to treating other humans with compassion, kindness, and understanding as the rule is a good one (if not the “best”). But any road which makes condemnig others, conceit (as in “I MUST BE RIGHT!”), and spreading/supporting prejudices is a down right disgusting one to me. This is the Christian that I abhor.

Gotta go, glad to see the family involved, and I already miss my hometown after being back for a week and a half. It won’t stop raining here. By the way, statements which paint all southerners as ignorant, redneck, hicks who hate everybody who is not like them are just as much examples of ignorance as saying all gays are evil. The south, like most places, has many people. Some of them cool, some of them loving, some of them cruel, and some of them hating. All broad sweeping statements are never true and do no one any good*.

DaLovin’ Dj

*Yes I see the irony in using the word “All” here. It is intentional, so spare me the logic game.

Thank you, DJ. In the spurt of posts, I had missed Jjrt’s beautiful testimony. God go with you and your family.

Thank you my loving handsome nephew. Why haven’t you emailed me??? DJ and I do get into some heated arguements but he’s been arguing since he was born. I would’ have told everyone here who I was but I waiting for you to do that . I saw your pics at the dopefest.
You may find out a lot of things you didn’t know about me on this board. I’ve found a few things out about you (and some an aunt shouldn’t be reading) Love ya

:shifts around uncomfortably:

Ummm, yeah, the board and my posts are of a pretty frank nature from time to time. I don’t even want to think about what drunken posts you may run across. To prevent a further hijack of this thread, why don’t you come over and say hello in this welcome thread, and then step over to the pit thread I started to reveal my embarrasing childhood stories or yell at me for old posts you may find. I know how you hate cuss words (yeah, right) . . .

I must say I have been impressed with the amount and the quality of information you have posted here. Regardless of whether we differ in opinion, you have obviously studied your religion very much and those studies will surely help others learn (what this site is all about at its heart) if you stick around. Vice versa holds true as well. These kids around here are some of the smartest I’ve run into and have alot to offer to one who listens. Good luck!

DaLovin’ Dj

I think the term “uncovering her nakedness” is a euphemism for “having sex with her”. It doesn’t just mean undressing someone.

Originally posted by Scotticher

Nothing anyone could ever say to me is going to convince me that I didn’t do exactly the right thing in caring for my mother, including the things I had to do to care for her that included “uncovering her nakedness.” Now, you may be a Biblical scholar, and you may know the original language, and you may tell me that the original language means something entirely different than what it seem to say.


Sctticher I done the same in caring for my Dad. I wouldn’t give it a second thought about it being wrong, maybe embarassing at times but never wrong. I think we would have been punished had we not cared for them.

Ephesians 6:1-9 - 1 Children, obey your parents in the Lord: for this is right. 2 Honour thy father and mother; (which is the first commandment with promise;) 3 That it may be well with thee, and thou mayest live long on the earth.

Many people claim to no longer be sinners after “recieving the gift of the Holy Ghost” and/or being baptized “in the name of Jesus Christ for the remission of sins”

Acts 2:38-39
38 Then Peter said unto them, Repent, and be baptized every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ for the remission of sins, and ye shall receive the gift of the Holy Ghost.

39 For the promise is unto you, and to your children, and to all that are afar off, even as many as the Lord our God shall call.
KJV

The strongs concordance definition for remission refers to the translation:
NT:859
aphesis (af’-es-is); from NT:863; freedom; (figuratively) pardon:

KJV - deliverance, forgiveness, liberty, remission.

This freedom, deliverance and liberty–many people believe–is permanent.

The bible says clearly that “all HAVE sinned, and have come short of the Glory of god”(Romans 3:23)

However, Paul further adresses the Roman Christians(church) in:

Rom 6

6:1 What shall we say then? Shall we continue in sin, that grace may abound?
2 God forbid. How shall we, that are dead to sin, live any longer therein?

4 Therefore we are buried with him by baptism into death: that like as Christ was raised up from the dead by the glory of the Father, even so we also should walk in newness of life.

7 For he that is dead is freed from sin.
KJV

Paul goes on to talk about dying to sin then says

Rom 6:15
15 What then? shall we sin, because we are not under the law, but under grace? God forbid.

The whole chapter(Romans 6) talks about not sinning.
Some pastors teach that we are all born sinners, but that through Christ we can be sinners no more, but be saints of god.

To me, it seems concurrent with the bible.

That was my point…it SAYS “uncovering her nakedness.” I PRESUME it means having sex with her. If I were to take the words literally, it would mean I sinned by taking care of her. I was just trying to show that God gave us a heart and a brain and He expects us to USE them in order to interpret Scripture correctly. Along with other more explicit Scriptures and the Holy Spirit, who…if present…should be there to HELP you interpret Scripture.

I’m glad you had the opportunity to care for your dad, jjrt…I hope it gives you as much comfort that you were able to DO so as it does me that I was able to care for my mom.

I don’t necessarily think we would have been “punished” if we HADN’T been able to be there for them, (my brothers and sister seemed to do quite well regardless of what they did…or rather DIDN’T do) but I DO have to say that the time I spent with my mom while caring for her toward the end of her life was worth more to me than I can begin to tell you. I wouldn’t take a million dollars in exchange for what I gained.