I have a Kindle Keyboard (hey, Kindles have been around long enough to have old-school versions now!) and I love it, although I would have considered myself a hard-line physical book lover. I’ve had it for two and a half years now, and I’ve been thinking about the Paperwhite, because I think the brighter background is prettier, and because I’m not all that enamored of the keyboard.
The library feature is incredible. Details may depend on your library, but mine lets me check out six books at a time, for up to three weeks each. My library (perhaps like all libraries?) uses the Overdrive Media Console. It was very easy to set up, and it’s outrageously easy to use. When I check out books, I click on the download button, choose the Kindle format, and the link opens an Amazon page where I can click on a button to have the book sent to my Kindle via wi-fi. If I want to return a book early (almost always), I can do that through the “Manage my Kindle” page on Amazon, and that opens up another slot in my library account. The only drawback I’ve found is a somewhat limited availability of Kindle-format ebooks (there are a lot of them, but I’m impossibly demanding). When my library first started offering Kindle books, there were a few hiccups (it sometimes took a long time for a returned book to register on the library site), but those smoothed out wonderfully over six months or so.
You can read magazines and newspapers on the Kindle, but it’s not great for graphics. The smallish screen doesn’t really lend itself to those formats, either. Because I chose the Kindle specifically for its non-back-lit screen, I’m willing to overlook that, and I just read those things on my laptop instead. Oh, and that’s another bonus: you can read your Kindle books on up to three other devices as well. And there’s the “Cloud” reader, which lets you access your library from any computer. You do have to choose only one device to download your library books to, but any content you own can be accessed from any of the devices you’ve chosen.
My Kindle crashed once, but I was able to talk to an Amazon representative through a live chat, and she walked me through the process of restoring all my content. I had to re-create my “Collections” (a way to group the books), but otherwise it was seamless.
I’d recommend the Kindle pretty whole-heartedly, but I’d also like to hear some opinions from people who’ve upgraded to the Paperwhite from an older e-ink version.