Kosher to forward a Virus?

Two part question:

Ya know those unscrupulous lowlifes (some based in Nigeria) who prey on the unsuspecting? The subject’s been covered on the boards so hopefully most of y’all are familiar with 'em.

http://spl.haxial.com/nigerian-fraud/

Well I’ve been contacted by one and it just so happens I’ve also been inundated with attempts to infest me with SoBig(Part II coming up).
I can pretty much tell which ones they are after scanning one for viruses.
About 100k by the way, so watch out!

Sooo… Part I: Is it cool to forward one of these alleged virus infected attachments to the bad guys?
Would I be lookin’ at a Federal offense?

Part II: The SoBig letters I’m getting contain subject lines that pertain to some of my areas of interest. It’s like someone I know is targeting me.
Is that the case or was my name just grabbed from a list somewhere?
Still seems like someone is spending a bit of time trying to zap me specifically.

Any thoughts Dopers?

Sending out or forwarding a virus is never cool, imho, ymmv.

I’d have to agree with Optihut. While passing a virus to the Nigerian scammers might seem like giving them their just reward for being such a waste of skin, doing so will only help the virus to spread further.

“Well, officer. I didn’t make the gun. I just used it. What d’you mean you don’t see the difference!?”

Apparently it is kosher to forward a virus, but a rabbi has to witness you clicking the send button.

No, mrsam, a rabbi has nothing to do with kashrut. A moshgiach (who often is, but does not have to be, a rabbi) has to supervise the entire process, including verifying that the virus’ code is indeed kosher. Kashrut is best thought of as a quality control process.

In my opinion, a computer virus counts as a swarming creature, which the Torah specifically says is NOT kosher. Therefore, my interpretation of Leviticus is that it is not kosher to forward any treif code.

Also, there is a commandment (I believe in Deuteronomy, section Ki Tetze) saying: “Justice, justice shall you pursue.” This also translates as: “Righteous justice shall you pursue.” The means must be as valid as the ends; sending a destructive computer virus to a spammer is not righteous justice.

It IS poetic justice, though! :slight_smile:

A Trojan (or is it a worm?) has read some of your e-mail, so it knows certain words that you use. Just like David Blaine does. Except more sophistacted.