Less effort to obscure vulgarity in print cartoons?

It used to be, in the old days, that a comic strip character might occasional spout out an exclamation of “@#$%*!”. It was up to the reader’s imagination to decide what might that might represent. It was artful to see a generic outburst voiced by a character while avoiding anything that would offend the sensibilities of the average reader.

There has been more a trend these days, possibly associated with the general decline of civilization, of using a more obvious statement. Rather than being generic, it substitutes in a more well-known phrase for the obvious word. The watershed moment for me was this week, in the Washington Post, where a punchline was “Tell him to #$%* off”.

This seems to be a general trend, though, more like blacking out a word rather than the artful cartoonist’s rendition of “he said something bad”. I have seen others like, “What the @%?" or "I don't give a @*&.” I expect this kind of thing in alternative papers (heck, even just spell it out) but this seems to now be a trend in mainstream cartooning.

It’s not that I personally find it offensive. This is not a complaint–I am just noting what looks to me like a trend. I am wondering if professional cartoonists discuss this sort of thing. Are there any reading this?

IANAPC, but I know several of them. Cartoonists have always tried to push the envelope to see how much they can get away with, and syndicate and newspaper editors have made them tone it down so as not to offend the gentle eyes of newspaper readers at the breakfast table. If there’s been a change, I’d say it’s probably due to a change in the attitudes of editors rather than cartoonists.

There’s a story that one of Mort Walker’s editors used to take a razor blade and scratch out the navels on the women in Beetle Bailey because they were too suggestive. Walker got back at him by drawing a strip where Camp Swampy received a huge shipment of navel oranges (in cartons with women in bikinis on the labels). The editor let it go through.

Hadn’t thought about that…I guess it makes sense that cartoonists would have a rebellious streak (except maybe Bil Keane).

I was surprised to see Stephan Pastis use the word “turd”–twice, no less–in Pearls Before Swine a few days ago.