No, the OP pointed out that all of the unconventionally attractive women in that thread were model thin. She requested photos of women who were beautiful and “aren’t thin.”
If you look up ‘muffin top’ on google images there are some decent photos. The faces are always cropped out though.
http://www.jesseliebman.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/04/muffin-top.jpg
Amber Benson isn’t thin. And she is beautiful.
But, fine – she’s not fat enough for you guys so I withdraw the suggestion.
This argument is far too stupid to participate in any further.
I gotta agree with Diosa,zweisamkeit, olives, etc.
There’s a subtle difference at play here, but I think the OP is asking for pictures of women who are demonstrably “not model thin”.
Crystal Renn is gorgeous. Queen Latifah is beyond that. And I had to step away from computer for a bit when I saw Nigella Lawson! Mrrrrow!
Uh, put me in the same boat as Olives and co. I laughed when I saw the first two submissions.
“But they aren’t super model thin!” “I was taking “a few extra pounds” literally!” Come on, guys. Come on.
Don’t want to go searching for photo evidence on my friend’s computer, but if you’re into tattoos and piercings and stuff, the Suicide Girls website has plenty of beautiful big girls.
Having seen them all together in person, I have to say that Benson (at least at the time) was quite thin, and SMG and Charisma Carpenter were borderline skeletal.
Same goes for America Ferrera. The ‘Hm, I thought he’d be taller’ thing isn’t a myth for (many) actors, and when you’ve got short guys you need even shorter, smaller-boned women (or else, horrors, they may be larger than their on-screen boyfriend, husband, whathaveyou. *That '70s Show *aside).
If you folks want to see a buncha ladies who have a respectable poundage, just tune in to any QVC fashion show and wait till they bring out the X’s.
I once was so inspired by them that I wrote a poem about it.
These are the saddest of possible words,
One X to two X to three.
A group of large ladies, to bulky for words,
One X and two X and three.
Gulping deserts with unrestrained passion,
Then bursting anew the limits of fashion
These gals underwent a most startling expansion,
One X to two X to three.
I wanted to send it in to QVC but my wife wouldn’t let me.
Looks like not enough s’s in deserts. Just mentally add one.
How about America Ferrera?
Whitney Thompson, the “plus size” girl from America’s Next Top Model?
I also think Jennifer Hudson is gorgeous.
I’ll agree with some caveats - Amber Benson does not have a few extra pounds. Holocaust victims look pleasantly plump next to Charisma Carpenter. (And rather less orange.) On the other hand, Christina Hendricks is often quite fleshy - I don’t know if she’s been pregnant lately because I don’t know anything about her personal life, but several times I’ve seen pictures of her at events in the past year her arms are definitely in the “kind of chubby” zone. And of course she’s a mega-hottie. I wouldn’t go gay for Christina because the woman does not know how to dress herself, but I’d go gay for Joan. 
Sara Rue. (more) Her weight has fluctuated. There were times when she was a bit too heavy, but she lost too much weight for my tastes at one point.
Apparently she’s gained some of it back, if the labels on this pic are correct: 2001/2005/2009
She has a sexy role in a movie For Christ’s Sake which hasn’t been released yet.
Raquel Welch. Even today.
Mmmm. I looves me some Liis.
Miranda Lambert is just gorgeous (YouTube, music video).
Too bad. Most people today think skinny people are more attractive. The number of attractive plus-sized women in media is painfully small. And most seem to require heavy makeup and/or weird poses for people to call them beautiful (as evidenced in this thread).
I wasn’t going to say anything, but seeing the treatment Knorf got for daring to pick someone he does not consider thin, but not fat enough for you, I really don’t care about how I make you guys feel.
Can we say “woof”?
ETA: Queen Latifah is what I’d consider mildly attractive, in a friend sort of way. But Margaret Cho? Bow wow.