Let's write some new constitutional amendments

This topic has come up before, but it looks like it’s been a while, and the last few years have been…eventful. Just for fun, let’s take a stab at writing some amendments to the U.S. Constitution that could, in theory, be attractive enough to all bands of the political spectrum that they have a greater-than-zero chance of getting ratified. I’ll start. :slight_smile:

Amendment XXVII

Section 1.
The President may not grant Reprieves or Pardons for Offenses against the United States to him- or herself.

Section 2.
Any Reprieve or Pardon for Offenses against the United States granted by the President may be overturned and rendered null and void by a vote of two-thirds of both Houses of Congress, provided that such vote is held within 60 days of the grant of the Reprieve or Pardon.

Amendment XXIX

Section 1.
No Officer of the United States, including the President and Vice-President, shall enjoy immunity from prosecution for any act committed while holding Office, except where provided by Congress.

Section 2.
The Congress shall have power to enforce this article by appropriate legislation.

Amendment XXX
The President shall have the Power to withdraw from any Treaty, provided two-thirds of the Senators present concur.


Regarding my proposed 28th Amendment, I’m not stuck on a 60-day window, but that seemed short enough that people receiving a pardon wouldn’t be in limbo for too long, but also gives Congress time to act if they wish.

For my proposed 29th Amendment, I had initially left off the, “except where provided by Congress,” but I could envision Congress agreeing to grant some sort of immunity for certain aspects of certain offices. But, I think the default state should be that Officers should think about the potential for prosecution when making decisions.

Re: my proposed 30th this has, to the best of my knowledge, never really been addressed in any court cases. To my mind, if it takes the concurrence of the Senate to enact a Treaty, it should take the same concurrence to withdraw. Let’s get that in the Constitution.

There’s lots of other things I’d like to see changed about our government, but a lot of them can (and maybe should) be done by statute. I didn’t propose anything altering the 2nd Amendment because I think it’s just a non-starter. I wouldn’t mind giving the ERA another try, but that’s essentially already written, so no need for us to have a go at it.

I’d like to think that if we had, say, a Democratic President and one or both Houses of Congress under Republican control, that these would have a shot (since they would necessarily limit the power of a Democratic President as well as another Republican President), but I recognize that there are very long odds against this happening.

Politicians have to pass the background checks necessary to gain top secret clearance. Failure to pass results in disqualification to run.

Politicians who lie are treated with the same accountability lawyers who lie are treated with.

Abolish the death penalty, put teeth in the emoluments clause, overturn the Supreme Court’s presidential immunity decision.

Congress and the states may regulate and set reasonable limits on the raising and spending of money by candidates and others to influence elections.

Stop there and you’re good. Presidential pardons are an antiquated extension of royal prerogative that has no place in a system defined by rule of law. If you insist on some sort of pardon authority, put it in the hands of a non-partisan Board of Clemency instead of making it subject to the whims of one man.

Im not sure how you would do it, but I would like like to see something about provably and deliberately false statements by and to the media.

It would need to be narrow and very very factual, but given the reach and irresponsibilty of certain media, i think its time to bring some sort of factual reliability back to public discourse.

If they are rich and influential they get, at best, a slap on the wrist?

Putting the words “may” and “reasonable” in a Constitutional Amendment will be confusing and manipulating to the max. “May” also means “Or may not” and “reasonable” just isn’t possible.

Abolish the death penalty, except for people who drive slow and hog the left lane on highways.

In all states that sentence someone to death, there must be an option for that person to be a citizen of another country providing said country is willing to make said person a citizen of theirs. There will be a limit of five living potential citizens per country-When one dies, another one can be let in. The country involved will be the sole decider of who gets in. Said person that qualifies will never be allowed back into the U.S. for any reason, and this limitation cannot be changed by the President and/or Congress.

Anyone serving in elected or appointed senior federal office (House, Senate, President, SCOTUS) must complete an annual health (physical and mental) evaluation by a party of 3 non-partisan health professionals, where any health concerns that could affect their performance of their duties will be made available to eligible voters.

If you choose to run for office, you must do the same or provide equivalent information verified in the last year.

Yes, this may discourage some for running for office, and this is (to me TBC) an acceptable compromise after years of politicians on both sides taking far too many risks.

And the final choice if said issues are a concern are the voters - if we want to elect someone with depression, cancer, or STDs, well, that’s still our right.

I like @ParallelLines ’ take better. If a candidate for elected office wouldn’t pass a security clearance, then let the people know that, but leave the actual decision up to the people. Which, yes, is still flawed, because people are idiots. But it’d be even more flawed any other way.

The problem with XXIX is that the impeachment clause appears to give the specific process by which a President may be (in effect) indicted and tried for a criminal offense. Certainly it is possible that if the President, say, shot somebody on 5th Avenue, the courts would allow prosecution without prior impeachment for a “high crime” or “misdemeanor.” But that would seem to me to be in the hands of the courts.

Not a bad idea, but let’s make it apply at state and city level. And also try to prevent tricks such as: Trump resigns on Jan 18th, President Vance is sworn in and pardons Trump.

No official having the power of pardon may pardon themself. No person that temporarily assumes an office during the absence of the incumbent may pardon the incumbent. No official may pardon his predecessor during the first three months of his office.

It is normal for elected officials to have immunity - but only from official acts. So far, afaik, trump has not benefited from his “immunity”.

If 2/3rd of the senate agrees, there is no need for the Executive.

Local politicians also? Dogcatcher?

I can see this for some Congress committees where Secret stuff is discussed. So, a simple majority Congress vote does this.

Indeed, the various States can prosecute the Executive for non-official crimes today. trump was convicted in NY.

The issue with excluding “official” crimes is that some county , upset that the President ordered a attack by smart bomb somewhere in the world, could arrest and convict hims of Murder.

See this-
https://constitution.congress.gov/browse/essay/artI-S6-C1-3-1/ALDE_00013300/

Article I, Section 6, Clause 1:

The Senators and Representatives shall receive a Compensation for their Services, to be ascertained by Law, and paid out of the Treasury of the United States. They shall in all Cases, except Treason, Felony and Breach of the Peace, be privileged from Arrest during their Attendance at the Session of their respective Houses, and in going to and returning from the same; and for any Speech or Debate in either House, they shall not be questioned in any other Place.

Basically what we have is several amendments that really only effect one current president, who will be gone in a couple years, and can not be passed until he is gone in any case.

The issue isn’t necessarily depression, cancer or STIs. We’ve had presidents with these while in office and they functioned fine. Lots of US presidents had anxiety, depression, bipolar, substance abuse, etc and they functioned fine.

Background checks are ideally to determine if you are going to be blackmailed, have poor moral character, are easy to bribe, are mentally ill to the point of being incompetent.

Yup, and you absolutely don’t want people in office of poor moral character or who are bribable or blackmailable. But it you make the security clearance an absolute requirement, what happens when the person who decides security clearances is corrupt?

I think it’s worth asking, before proposing any constitutional change that makes holding office more onerous or restricts who can run or grants the government powers it didn’t have before; “Would you want Donald Trump and a Republican Congress to have this power/be in charge of that?”

You want to penalize the media for reporting falsehoods? Fine, if you’re OK with what Stephen Miller would be able to do as Secretary of Truth.

Yep, they could deny Security clearances for nearly every Dem candidate.

All financial transactions greater than $1000 (adjusted for inflation) made the president, vice president, Supreme Court, members of the cabinet and members of Congress must be made public.

The president shall be determined by the winner of a plurality of cast votes.

The threshold for impeachment conviction in the Senate shall be reduced to 3/5.

The problem with this is who runs the security clearance checks? Suppose this was active today with Patel in charge.