You think the case is good?
Ok, maybe not “good”. But I can see what mahaloth is saying.
Biotop, what have you noticed from the vote record?
I also see what **Mahaloth ** is saying. I want to hear **HN ** explain his thought process. I asked him and am still waiting.
That said, it does bother me that **Mahaloth ** “defintely” thinks I am Town because I made a case. When I am Scum I try and make cases too. Doesn’t that seem odd to you SNF? Or is it just my general paranoia towards players who trust me early on?
It could be a little from column A and a little from column B.
Also, just noticed that Hi, neighborino is in the highly controversial beerzone from D1. Again, it is not slam dunk evidence by any means. Just…interesting.
Not much. I didn’t think Professor Pepperwinkle was particularly Scummy, but he does often draw votes early. If **HN ** or you turn out to be Scum there will be opportunity for reevaluation.
The trouble is we do not have a database of **HN ** games to see if his play is an aberration or if the BZ is his normal level of participation.
I rarely see prof as scummy. But I see a lot of myself in him in that we both cant resist a joke and draw votes for it. Often easy scum votes.
Yes. But Prof. P does tend to post less when Scum. I think that is his biggest tell. When he is Town he is quite comfortable posting a lot. Less so when Scum.
Subtlety so, but yes. I agree.
Gotta go to bed. It looks like the impending hurricane is going to cut my vacation a day short. A small inconvenience to my wife and I, a lot worse for others I suspect.
Nighty night, and be safe. In the morning, let me know if you’ve picked up any scum tells on sunny yet. I think she’s only been in like 3 or 4 games with me.
I’m sticking with my original accusation. That cheery disposition and red sweater don’t fool me.
Vote Hi, Neighbor
Another scum trying to frame me. After we say “Bye, Neighbor,” don’t think I won’t forget this…
How do you figure I “reverse-engineered” a reason to vote for you?
I made it pretty clear towards the end of Day 1 (where you conveniently disappeared, mind you) that it irked me that you had voted for **Stranger **then never even came back to the thread until the following night when Stranger had already been lynched.
Just go back and read post #366:
Had I not been in the situation I was in, I would have gladly voted for you instead. But the only way for me to possibly live was to vote for Stranger. And this, by the way, was all at the suggestion of Prof. Pepperwinkle (#364).
Up until that point I had not even considered a move like that and was ready to accept my fate.
I can’t believe no one is really addressing this.
Does no one find it fishy?
Sure, **Biotop **is actively doing a lot of analysis, but I think at this point even HE must be a little surprised his last minute vote isn’t getting more attention. No one seems to be talking about it. Why?
Pardon my ignorance, but what is the “beerzone”?
I had a long response typed up, but I think I’d prefer you to explain what you find fishy about this vote.
Just the fact that it was literally cast in the last minute of Day 1 and broke a tie that led to me being saved and Stranger being lynched.
I mean, **snoe **kind of addressed it in post #446, but it didn’t really gain a lot of traction.
And even after **snoe **broke it down like that, I am the one getting votes today? I voted **Stranger **, sure, but **Biotop **SAVED me and cast the vote that directly led to **Stranger **being lynched. Yet I am the one getting votes. That shit just doesn’t add up.
Why would I garner votes today when **Biotop **made arguably the scummiest move to end Day 1?