I agree, probably a good move for scum. I didn’t agree with Normal Phase on a lot of things, but he was definitely a provocateur for discussion and it seems we need that very much, it seems.
I think it’s worth considering peeker’s status at this point. There’s nothing in the rules that prohibits a scum Commissar, and his move on Hal works pretty much equally well for town or scum motives. If he’s scum, he gets basically a free pass at a Town player; sure, he’s in the Brig, but he’s alive and it’s not like scum can’t spare one of their four players, either.
I’m not going to vote for him, since he is in the Brig after all, and I don’t see a point to releasing him today when we could be Brigging someone else (presumably). I just don’t want it to be considered a town confirm.
I’m not sure I get the logic of your suggestion, TexCat. If Inner dies, but you promote Red Skeezix, in the end glowacks still takes the doc spot. Can you explain more about what you’re going for here?