What BlasterMaster said. Is it better to have the non confirmeds make cases pro and con or should we divvy it up and present to the apparent high council? Or a combo of both?
NETA: I’ll be looking at everyone. I was meremy suggesting a focus.
I still don’t Trust Ryjae, and I think the bastard needs to die.
(And fine, Blam… I’ll accept that you’re most likely Town…
But an evil Gastard Townie at that. Whee! I can use the term too now!)
But I’m of the mind that this miller stuff is a crock of shyte, and the boy needs a good hanging to sort him out.
However, of the 3 of us “unconfirmed”, I believe Bufftabby is most likely to be the scum just based on the way she’s interacted around BLaM for the whole time- I still have a gut feeling against her- as Nanook, well I get a non harmful vibe from the dude’s actions, but Bufftabby has just been irritatingly suspicious especially with her whole “dude, I’m totally not scum, so that’s why it’s okay if I act scummy” sorta defenses. So I’m down for stretching those two, but i feel WAY WAY more confident on Ryjae.
In fact: Vote Ryjae.
Vote Ryjae.
Bah.
Well, when your explanation of why snuggling is scummy consists of “because that’s what scum does” what kind of defense do you expect? I can’t answer charges you aren’t truly making. Not to mention that you totally, like, ordered me to stop doing it. I’m supposed to stop doing something because you say it’s scummy? What a load of shit. You can make your own damn decisions, but you sure as shit can’t make mine for me. I hardly think differences in style make a great case. Fuck it, I’m gonna
vote RoOsh.
You’re just too damn townie-wannabe for me. Feel free to call this an OMGUS vote, but that’s simply not the case. You’ve been totally on my ass since you stepped through the door, and I don’t feel like you’re really even looking for explanations; you just wanna lead a townie to death at the hands of fellow townies.
I can take criticism and suspicion, that’s all fine and good. The way you’ve been going after me makes me feel like you’re some sort of zealot, with faith born of Perfect Knowledge that I’m a townie. This is also influenced by the fact that I’m now feeling far less inclined to vote Nanook, and that only leaves you and me right now, buddy. Tag, you’re it.
:dubious: Once again, we’ve gone over this. It’s not “because that’s what scum does” - It’s just ANTI-TOWN. PERIOD. Townies and Scum both can do it, however, Townies should realize that what they’re doing is just mucking up the waters, and is NOT HELPFUL, so that’s why they often stop doing it.
The fact that you don’t WANT to understand this, and at this point are just deliberately trying to justify the fact that “I like doing it because I know I’m not scum” is just a terrible explanation, and reeks of newbie scum.
Oh okay. I guess since you said it, it’s probably not an OMGUS. Totally. Since you know, you said you’re not scum, and that’s pretty much your defense. Since you know what you are, I should trust you about that sorta thing. But thanks for voting for someone for being “TOO Townie for my taste.”
*Though you are right, it’s not an OMGUS, because I never voted for you. This was like a pre-emptive OMGUS, just because I actually called suspicion on you and have been for the last few Days. I’m voting for the scummiest person right now to me, you’re voting for what reason exactly? The Towniest? :dubious:
What, you don’t wanna vote for your scumbuddy: Ryjae. He’s just chopped liver in the corner there? Nice way of TOTALLY ignoring him in your little attack on me. I def. think you two are in bed with each other. I didn’t even VOTE for you toDay, I voted for Ryjae, but you get all uppity and start calling for MY death instead of a guy that’s been CALLED OUT AS SCUMMY by a CONFIRMED detective? What kinda crap smoke and mirrors play is that?
Most uncool, Buffy, most uncool.
:dubious:
But he didn’t even vote for you FCS. This feels like an OMGYS vote without even an OMGYS reason. Kind of weird I must say.
Day 1 Final Result : Mennocchio is Townie
2 - bufftabby (WF Tomba, Menocchio)
1 - WF Tomba (pedescribe)
1 - Queen of Town (peekercpa)
2 - MadTheSwine (Sitnam, ShadowFacts)
1 - ShadowFacts (MadTheSwine)
5 - Menocchio (fluiddruid, bufftabby, Roosh, Blaster Master, Nanook of the North Shore)
2 - peekercpa (NAF1138, Mind Wanderer)
1 - fluiddruid (Queen of Town)
1 - No Lynch (Ryjae)
Day 2 Final Result: MAD was the LEAD ASSASSIN
1 - Blaster Master (peekercpa)
5 - pedescribe (NAF1138, Ryjae, fluiddruid, MadTheSwine, Nanook of the North Shore)
5 - MadTheSwine (WF Tomba, Sitnam, ShadowFacts, bufftabby, pedescribe)
2 - fluiddruid (Blaster Master, Mind Wanderer)
1 - No Vote (Roosh)
Day 3 Final Vote: Fluiddruid is Townie
1 - bufftabby (pedescribe)
1 - Roosh (NAF1138)
2 - pedescribe (RyJae, peekercpa)
1 - Mind Wanderer (Nanook of the North Shore)
1 - Nanook of the North Shore (Blaster Master)
5 - fluiddruid (ShadowFacts, Mind Wanderer, WF Tomba, bufftabby, fluiddruid)
1 - No Vote (Roosh)
Day 4 Final Vote: Mind Wanderer is an Assassin
2 - RyJae (RoOsh, pedescribe)
5 - Mind Wanderer (ShadowFacts, NAF1138, peekercpa, Blaster Master, Nanook of the North Shore)
2 - Nanook of the North Shore (bufftabby, RyJae)
1 - No Vote (Mind Wanderer)
What does all this mean now? Well, I’m not seeing a whole lot to go on from it, except that at least my analysis of Mind Wanderer was well founded.
One thing that’s interesting is that all three of our unknowns voted for Menocchio on Day 1. Perhaps there’s something to be gained from rereading the reasonings for those votes.
An interesting pattern with Nanook is that he’s always the last vote on a bandwagon except for Day 3 when he voted for Mind Wanderer. Scum wagon jumping or impressionable townie?
Also, if Nanook is scum, that means that all 3 of the lynch candidates Yesterday were scum. I’m not sure what that would mean just yet, but I’m inclined to think it’s a point in favor of Nanook.
And just to poke the ant hill a bit. I was looking at the notes I have been taking throughout the game and the name that comes up most frequently is Nanook of the North Shore. It will probably be tomorrow when I can sit at my “big” computer then I’ll try to reference the posts that I thought kind of funky.
Going back to re-read, again.
No it means that I am a miller, which I’m pretty sure I was saying anyway. I don’t know how I got to be this fantastic town killed probability role, but thems the facts.
I still think Nanook is the scummiest of the players in the unknown group, followed closely by bufftabby and even closer behind her is RoOsh (because of zuma… sadly because RoOsh as RoOsh seems more town than our confirmed town)
But my vote will likely go on the “bandwagon” of those three, because I think the same points Yesterday apply today. I am a known item, turned up scum but I’m not, but if we can eliminate the remaining scum day after day I can be alive for the win. Without town needing to lynch me to see I’m telling the truth. So yeah its self preservation, with a lot of sense added 
Uh huh. I’ll believe it when you explain what’s so wrong with it. “It muddies up the waters” is not the most descriptive phrase in the world. My defense does not consist of your fake quote above, but more along the lines of “I haven’t seen a compelling reason not to do something I only do occasionally anyway and do not see how it could be harmful, but boy am I glad RoOsh is around to tell me what to do”.
I didn’t say the towniest. I said town-wannabe. Which is, ya know, what scum would be.
Oh, I guess you’re right. Everyone who went for a complete unknown yesterday must be in bed with RyJae as well. If she’s really scum, there’s one other scum (according to the generally accepted numbers we have at this point) in th pool of unknowns. If she’s really the Miller, there’s one scum in the pool of unknowns. It makes more sense to wait, seeing as how if she is really the Miller, we could avoid a mislynch by eradicating the scum in the unknown pool, saving the ryjae vote for if there are still even scum remaining after we find the scum in our unknowns.
If there’s not an OMGUS reason, it’s not so much of an OMGUS vote, is it? Please note where RoOsh has taken it upon himself to be my Grand Inquisitor, not to mention ordering me to behave in a way he sees fit. He has been riding my ass for Days now, for no tangible reason that I can find. He’s not really interested in any explanations I give, just in how he can turn that around to make me look scummier. It doesn’t feel like a townie inquisition, it feels like Perfect Knowledge scummitude.
Hey everyone - checking in from vaca. Given that we got scum yesterday (excellent), I think we are in a good position to continue what we did then, i.e. leave RyJae for now and look at the remaining unconfirmeds. Nanook gets a couple points in my book for making a decent case against MindWanderer, which caused me to look at him and make MY case, which got the ball rolling yesterDay and netted us scum. Obviously, that doesn’t mean he’s NOT scum, but it’s enough for me to focus my limited attention elsewhere toDay.
So, at this early moment, I would say that my vote is likely to end up on either bufftabby or Roosh (despite their bickering). I could be convinced otherwise by a compelling case for RyJae or Nanook, but that’s where I’m leaning at the moment.
Upthread bufftabby alludes to RyJaye as she. Compelling question that has a factual answer, I hope:
RyJaye be you penis possesor or penis envyor?
I think he possesses a Penis. But I am unsure.
:dubious: At this point, BOTH BlaM and I have tried to explain this to you, and you’ve not changed. So fine. But why don’t you go back and read HIS thoughts on it if I’m the one bugging you so much, and maybe he’ll come across as a nicer gentler reason to stop.
Yeah. If by “Everyone” you mean THE THREE of Us! :smack: There are 3 unknowns here- You me and Nanook. Let’s look at the Day 4 votes:
- Roosh- votes for Ryjae- identified as Scum by a detective.
- Nanook- votes for Mindwanders, a now dead scum.
- Buffy- votes for Nanook.
And now today, once again, you seem disinterested in trying to vote for Ryjae, but would rather go after Nanook Roosh. What’supwithdat? :dubious:
Why suddenly your change from Him to Me- I’ve been riding your ass both Days, but suddenly you’re coming after me? I think at this point you’ve been the SCUMMIEST of the unknowns (You and Nanook that is) because of the way you’ve been going at it. I don’t understand your ideas that we should focus on the unknown rather than the KNOWN Scum Result that we have on Ryjae.
I say we lynch Ryjae, and then focus on the “unknowns,” but you have been quite vocal on focusing on the Unknowns and NOT on Ryjae, that to me is quite telling and suspicious, and makes me want to lynch him even more.
Well, no, I don’t mean three of us AT ALL. Pay attention this time. I said everyone who VOTED FOR one of us. We are the object here, not the subject. Let’s take a look:
Only ONE confirmed townie voted ryjae. Everyone else voted unknown. So, I ask you again: what makes it scummy that I believe in taking the same course of action that SEVEN different players found to be the best course of action yesterday?
Uh huh. See my above remarks. And quite vocal? I believe it was you who attacked me for not wanting to vote that way JUST LIKE MOST OTHER PLAYERS YESTERDAY. Next time I just won’t defend myself, so I won’t be accused of being “quite vocal” about it.
Oh, and why don’t you tell me when the last time I even did snuggle, since I am apparently so determined to continue doing so, to the great detriment of the town?
Hey, bufftabby where did your final vote land and in what position on the Mad lynch? I’d look it up if I wasn’t tied to this fu**ing BB.
Also, the fact that I am getting the brooms ready for Phoenix.
Peeker, I don’t remember presactly on the MtS vote, but I was last or next to last. I know, I know, totally damning evidence.
But that be my point arrrrr. It was from my recollection that you were late and stayed there. Nanook was early and then moved when the false claim was made. A claim that I don’t think anyone else would have bought based on its timing - unless they were scum trying to save their flippin’ LEADER.
Vote Nanook of the North Shore
Butt is it his penis?
Length of post is once again apologized for
Get it, length of post. Wink wink nod nod and butt and all that stuff…