Who you talkin’ to, CTTDSWHC?
:smack: Gadrene
SnakesCatLady has not voted for herself.
I didn’t vote for myself because I know I’m not scum.
I’m also not allowed two votes!
Picky picky! The first vote count I get even remotely wrong, and do I get cut any slack? No sir, I do not. Tough crowd. 
Corrected Updated Vote Count
2 – Lightnin’ (DiggitCamara, Millit the Frail)
2 – CaerieD (Lightnin’, SnakesCatLady)
2 – SnakesCatLady (Idle Thoughts, CaerieD)
1 – nesta (Hal Briston)
Now I’m left wondering what Gadarene would do if we did start voting for ourselves…
Depends on whether or not you could get enough people to go along with you. 
Ahh, I’ll keep that in mind for the next game. 
ummm… a question for Gadarene (sorry if it has been asked before)
Can the scum communicate during the day in their secret thread?
Nope.
At the time that I made your favorite post (Page 9, #426), I was not aware that GMs sometimes manually assign roles, and I was apparently not alone in my ignorance.
tirial validates my observation shortly thereafter in post #428. I also nterpreted nesta’s more recent post as another validation of my gut reaction * at the time that I made the post*, i.e. prior to the revelation that GMs do indeed assign roles manually.
nesta then goes on to say that it was your reaction to my suspicion that he found curiously over-dramatic.
Going mainly by patterns:
The simple option has Blastermaster, CaerieD, Lightnin and Rachm Qoch as the remaining scum suspects.
The complicated option has Idle Thoughts, Hal Briston, Lemur866, and fluiddruid (rigd - Rest In Great Discomfort) as scum suspects.
I have absolutely no clue which one is right, if any, if at all. The truth is probably somewhere in between.
I’m tempted to vote for Lightnin’ because I did on Day two, and he’s only really given more ammuniton since. On the other hand, that’s the lazy option.
How long until the day ends? I’ve got reading to do.
Tomorrow at around 7 p.m. my time.
Understood. I personally disagree, but I understand.
Thing is, that was the first thing in this game that really, really jumped out at me, so I grabbed onto it. While going back through posts, it seems to me that was the only thing I had going against you. The basis for all the…what did you call them? Pokes? Jabs? Either way, that’s probably where they stem from. I don’t think I’ve found anything since, so you’re rapidly falling off my scumdar.
Trouble is, the bit about whether or not a GM would go non-random is no longer up for debate, and nesta knew that. However, he still brought up that even questioning it was odd. That is simply not the case. The only way it even becomes anywhere near worth mentioning is if nesta is scum attempting to push further suspicion my way.
Very clever move on the mafia’s part, actually. Just hope no one gets suckered by it.
Ah, I thought it was today at 7PM. Hence my panic! Still, I hope we can have a lot of good productive discussion before the lynch is upon us.
Whoops. :smack: Upon further review, you’re absolutely right. Better alert folk to that.
The day ends in four and a half hours. Just FYI.
Thanks, Millit.
Did I miss something? I thought we didn’t know how many Mafia exist in the game. I’ve been kind of working on the assumption that we started with four (which would leave us with three, unless there’s been a recruitment)- but that’s probably because I read someone else’s guess much earlier on.
So basically, you didn’t even read my answers to your questions.
Ah, I should add… I’m going to be out of town Thursday night through Saturday morning for an interview. This time I’ll be in the States, though, so my phone might allow me to read the thread and add small posts.
Man, I really need a laptop.
Oh, God! Panic!! :eek:
Only SEVEN people have voted. This is not good. More than half of the votes have yet to come in. The scum could totally pull something now. They could tip the scales in favor of any of our “nominees,” as no one has more than two votes right now. Or someone could go from zero to eight by nightfall. In any case, I’m going to be in class when IT happens. Oh, the agony!
I’m standing on my vote for Lightnin’. Tread carefully…but please vote!
Bah. I was thinking we had till tomorrow too.
I’m going to have to throw my vote in for Lightnin’.
With the top three people in the current vote tally already on my watch list, it came down to a preference of voting bedfellows. Choosing CarieD or SnakesCatLady would have put me in cahoots with some of the very same folks that am watching.
Time will tell if this will prove to be wise, dumb, or lucky.
You seem to have missed every post in the game refering to the number of mafia as 4-6. This is because less than 4 and the mafia usually don’t win, and more than 6 and they normally always win. Allowing for the recuit, this makes 4 or 5 the most likely starting number. With one gone, and a possible recruit the number is likely to be anywhere between 3 and 5.
Also you missed the fact I said “scum suspects” not scum, because I was flagging up the highest options in each case, not making definitive pronouncements.
Read them. You didn’t answer the questions about why you were incriminating yourself, or even whether you understood how your actions could be taken as incriminating.
And from your earlier post:
Can you understand why I might do the same thing? My Day Two target was you.