Mafia The Game III: Kinder and Gentler

Snipped some.

Well, two things. First of all, I still have that one in six chance, now don’t I? :wink:

Secondly, you’re not telling me anything I don’t already know. I know I’m pretty much screwed for this game…either by being killed off tonight or lynching today/tomorrow or something else…but when people like you and Diggit (who, again, did a complete 180 in his last post–pretty good scum tell) force votes on someone with a role, that’s what you get eventually.

So glad I’m not the only one who this hit hard in very shady behavior/inconsistancy.

I’ll keep my vote on SCL.

Not yet, although I do predict a no kill vote by the mafia tomorrow to maybe make people think so. Either that, or they’ll kill off someone who isn’t me to make me look like I’m lying in some way (either at not being recruited or not being the NW at all).

But I don’t see how that would work.
After all, if I were recruited, that would have been a pretty random guess on their part, agreed? And it would have had to have been ONE of the three nokill nights in a row, correct?

So, that means on TWO of those days there had to have been a save. Sure they could have voted nokill all three of those nights or even just one but I don’t see why they’d waste a night.

So going under the belief that two of those days had to have been saves, it was either the Doc or me (or perhaps a combo of the two). Now, it being me both nights is pretty slim. It COULD have been but I just don’t feel it. I feel that they hit someone that first night, found they couldn’t, and tried hitting them again the next night just to be sure and found, again, they couldn’t. They then felt reasonably sure it was the Doc and recruited.

Even with the case that it was a combo of me and the Doc, it works, however in that case my save becomes redundant anyway if the Doc was self-protecting.
A recruitment of me, though, would be out of the blue and doesn’t make sense. Added to this, of course, being the main fact that I KNOW I’m still pro-town leads me to think it was the Doc, unfortunatly.

There is another case, too, but I think it’s actually less of a chance than me being lucky twice.

Could be they, on that first night, didn’t choose to hit tirial (or me for that matter), but another player. And this player was either the Doc or (if not) saved by me. But I don’t like that scenerio either. Just reads wrong and doesn’t make sense.

I waited as long as I could! I’m leaving practially in about half an hour/45 minutes. I couldn’t take the chance someone else would vote in that amount of time. I also wanted to, just in case, give myself some time to head off all or any debates or challenges over it as well.

Like I said, it’s unfortunate and I wish I had more time but I didn’t and didn’t want to take that chance. I thought about it for a full hour before starting the post above and figured that, in the end, I couldn’t take that chance. I waited for awhile to see if someone would cast another vote but it just seemed dead and time was running out (for me–the person who had the most votes at the time).

Me too, but if you’re really protown, don’t assume that WILL be the case. Like I said, they could nokill or kill off someone else entirely just to try to make people waver in trusting me.

Anyway, thank you for your trust. I really hope, if I ever do get killed–whether sooner or later–my death would help my team to a victory.

Heck, it might also be me making the save. Here’s hoping.

Well… that makes things interesting. So that probably means either a) You’re the Watchman; or b) You’re scum.

This is suspicious!

nesta offers to save your skin by switching votes to DiggitCamara, who you claim is more suspicious than SCL, yet you keep your vote on SCL nevertheless? IIRC, you say you’re 85% sure SCL is scum and 97% sure that DiggitCamara is scum. Ostensibly you are 100% sure you are town.

DiggitCamara has two votes from me and Cookies. If you and nesta were to vote DiggitCamara, you would be safe, and he’d be dead.

But for some reason you are willing to vote to lynch SCL, who you say is slightly less suspicious than DiggitCamara, whilst risking saving Diggit’s neck by risking your own (as well as SCL’s). Both you and nesta had been on my Questionmark List. I’d thought you were both less suspicious than DiggitCamara, but now I don’t know. If I were you, I’d reconsider your decision (assuming for the moment that you’re truly Watchman, of course.)

Wait, I don’t see a vote from Cookies. Was Gadarene wrong in his vote count, or did I miss Cookies’s vote somehow?

I think so! Cookies voted DiggitCamara back in Post #1870 and as far as I can tell he hasn’t unvoted him. By my reckoning SCL and Idle each have 3 votes, and DiggitCamara 2.

Crap, now I’ve been missing for all the action! I’m keeping my vote on SCL. I’m not so sure about Idle, but I feel like the votes against Diggit are coming out of left field and are mainly for personal reasons. I mean, he started the Lemur thing yesterday, practically out of nowhere. I think that alone means he deserves some more time to explain himself. He led a very effective bandwagon yesterday, and people are already chomping at the bit to lynch him today? That looks scummy on everyone but Idle Thoughts. I don’t feel like Diggit’s changes of heart are flip-flopping–it feels more like confused, wavering townie. I’ve been thinking about it more and more, and the Idle/Diggit thing really feels like a townie/townie fight. Let’s not lynch either–at least not today, OK?

hummmmmm, I posted about a half hour ago, but I guess the hamsters ate it.

I have 4 votes: Idle Thoughts, Hal Briston, Millet the Frail and nesta. I think Idle Thoughts went after DiggitCamera because he was defending me.

Ya’ll really need to look at zuma. Why would someone sub in and not participate?

The problem is, though, I’m convinced BOTH SnakesCatLady and **Idle Thoughts **are TOWN.

And right now Idle Thought’s posts are doing town a lot of harm. That was the main reason why I changed my vote from someone whom I suspect strongly of being scum to someone whom I pretty much know to be town to tie up the vote (unless he’s been recruited). That way it comes down to the salomonic decision of Random.org as to which townie will be lynched.

What?

I didn’t say that (or at least, I didn’t mean to say that). Look: if TWO KNOWN SCUM both tell you (practically at their deathbed) that they strongly suspect one player, isn’t it reasonable to think they are trying to apply reverse psychology so you lynch her as well?

Wonder why I’m not dead yet? Isn’t it past time? I figured Idle Thoughts would be in here to celebrate lynching another townie by now…

Sorry this is late and rushed. Memorial Day and all.

*As she is trundled toward the gallows, SnakesCatLady continues to protest her innocence. “Hear me, townspeople! I’m one of you!” She points from one to the next. “In fact, I’ve got a better voting record than you, and you, and you…and you, Goody Proctor! I voted for fluiddruid again and again, until people finally listened, and I voted for Lemur866 as well! You’re making a mistake!”

“That may be true,” says one of the townspeople. “But it is you who have made the bigger mistake. Never match wits with a group of Cecilians when death is on the line!”

“But—” says SnakesCatLady, and then it is too late.

SnakesCatLady, a citizen, is dead, with only her cats to mourn her.*
Everyone please submit your night instructions by Wednesday at 1:15 p.m. my time.

Good luck, townies. Someone feed my cats, will ya?

Well, I did my best to avert your death. :frowning:

Take care.

Grumble-grumble-grumble

That settles a few things for me, at least. I’m so sorry it went this way, though.

Sorry, SnakesCatLady, did my best.

Will feed the cats.

Sorry y’all, but my availability has been nil due to kitten-herding our friends and family around Vegas.

I don’t know what impact it may or may not have had, but I had voted for Diggit earlier in the day, so at the last vote count I saw he would’ve had 2.

Sorry to see you go, SCL. :frowning:

Hi everyone, I’m back! Did I miss anyth…ahhh, crap!

Remember those sincere apologies I mentioned, SCL? Well, they may not be doing much good now, but they’re still being sent your way. :frowning:

well, nobody feels worse than I do right now.

I’m not even going to apoligize because it wouldn’t even begin to make up for it.

Oh, for the love of God! I’m away from my computer for the weekend and all hell breaks loose…

So, whadda we think this time around? Are the scum going to be big meanies and use up their full time allotment, or will they hurry up and [del]make[/del] attempt their hit so we can get on with this?