99% of threads bitching about moderator actions are ludicrous. This one is not.
Now I know I’m going to get the ever-lovin’ shit flamed out of me for this, but I don’t give a fuck. I know that there are people who will stick up for manhattan, not because he’s right, but simply because he’s manhattan. I hate these people. IMHO, they don’t belong on a message board dedicated to fighting ignorance. They belong over at the Pizza Parlor or some other godawful message board where stupidity reigns supreme.
I have never had much of a problem with manhattan on other issues. Usually his judgement is fair and sound. The threads are moved where they’re supposed to be moved, and the bad threads are closed. Great job, manhattan - except, of course, for one little subject…
It is well known around this board that manhattan doesn’t like drug threads in GQ. IIRC, his reason for this was that they often denigrate into flame wars and debates.
Fair enough. If it turns into a debate, move it to GD. If it turns into a flame war, move it to the pit. That’s your job around here, isn’t it, manhattan? You used to be pretty good at this. You moved the bad drug threads, and usually left the ones that were genuine GQs stay. I understand that questions about drug manufacture or where to procure drugs are on legally shaky ground. To protect the Chicago Reader, these should be closed.
Lately, though, it seems that any question about any aspect of drug use is grounds for immediate closing. Interesting questions about the effects of drugs that could be of invaluable use to someone planning to take a drug are nixed without thought or regret. All this does is make drug use more dangerous. It makes the users ill-informed and more likely to do something stupid.
In this thread, Alias asks what a beer bong is. An innocuous question, right? It’s not like he asked how to make methamphetamines in his basement. He had a genuine General Question. The thread had NOT turned into a flame war. It had NOT turned into a debate. Manhattan couldn’t let that go. He had to jump in and say:
:rolleyes: There was nothing wrong with this thread and you know it, manhattan. Despite what you think, a drug question is not a deliberate attack on you. It is a request for information, like any other GQ. Why do you have to respond with an “I’m going to take my ball and go home” answer?
There are plenty of other hot button issues that often turn into debates when a GQ thread is posted about them. They simply get moved to their appropriate forum. Problem solved. I guess drugs are somehow different.
In another thread, friedo asks what a bong is. Apparently this question is so incredibly inflammatory that it needs to be shut down before the authorities see it. :rolleyes:
In that thread, JillGat said:
Perhaps. Virtually every question in GQ could be answered in some other place. Does that mean they should?
The problem with looking another place for drug info is that everyone has their own opinion on the issue and facts tend to get distorted or even made up. Pro-drug sites lie. Anti-drug sites lie. We know that if someone makes a bullshit assertion about drugs in a GQ thread, a more knowledgeable individual (hell, even a doctor!) will be along shortly to blow them out of the water.
So should we find another message board and ask the drug questions there? Yeah, right. Last time I checked, the vast majority of users on most other message boards aren’t even familiar with the Shift key. How can I expect them to give me accurate information?
In the first thread I linked to, Jomo Mojo said:
So just because manhattan has “issues,” the voices of hundreds of drug users on this board have to be stifled? Fuck that. Get over it, manhattan. If you can’t handle the drug threads, just ignore them and let another moderator keep an eye on them. How fucking difficult is that?
I am very interested in all aspects of illegal drugs - their use, abuse, effects, drug culture, etc, etc. It saddens me to no end to see the free expression of accurate drug information quashed like this.
Pretending things don’t exist doesn’t make them go away, manhattan…