Not sure if this is a factual question or a Great Debate - I’ll start it here in case there is a straightforward answer - if not, Mods feel free to move this.
I’m hoping someone on the Straight Dope can help me out here: My kid’s grade 12 social teacher has presented them with a ‘political axis’ that has altruism on one end and materialism on the other. She claims that political affiliation can be placed on this spectrum, with the right being more ‘materialistic’ and the left being more ‘altruistic’.
To me, this makes zero sense. Outside of partisan politics, how is materialism related to altruism in any way? How do they even belong on an axis together? I have never seen a definition of materialism that has anything to do with altruism or political affiliation.
The opposite of materialism isn’t altruism, it’s idealism. And the opposite of altruism is egoism, not materialism. If I refuse to help someone because I’m busy meditating, I may be selfish but it has nothing to do with materialism. And if the focus on my political activity revolves around the redistribution of material goods, I’m behaving materialistically, yet my concerns affiliate me with the ‘left’. For that matter, I thought Marxism was considered a ‘materialistic’ philosophy. So I don’t understand how such a spectrum could possibly make sense.
In addition, just wanting to redistribute wealth or have government help the poor does not make you altruistic. Altruism entails personal sacrifice - putting someone else’s needs ahead of your own. It’s not altruism to vote to have someone to take money from person A and give it to person B, if your own well-being is not involved. In fact, that desire can be completely selfish if A) you’re a person who would financially benefit from such a transfer, or B) you gain secondary benefit for supporting such policies by gaining political power, signalling your membership in a political group, or because it makes you feel better about yourself or helps you assuage guilt you feel over other moral failings. So that seems wrong too.
My kid is really struggling in this class because of this, whereas he’s always had straight A’s in previous social classes. Their last assignment was to take a whole bunch of ‘values’ like honesty, love, family, wealth, “World Peace” (not a value, but whatever - it was on the list) and then choose the ones they care about, put an ‘A’ or an ‘M’ next to them to signify whether they are ‘materialistic’ or ‘altruistic’, then determine from that whether they are on the right or the left based on the result.
To me, this seems like almost propaganda. She has created a false dichotomy by defining the ‘right’ as being materialistic, caring only about money, while the left is ‘altruistic’, and therefore values things like love, honesty, and family. With that dichotomy set up, the exercise was basically to put all the ‘nice’ things on the left and all the ‘bad’ things on the right. Of course the kids all discovered that they were leftists after that exercise.
But I would like to be fair to the teacher. Has anyone seen this formulation before? Is this part of the curriculum anywhere? Google turns up nothing. Given her obvious liking for Marx (she quotes Marx regularly and has a large poster of Che Guevara in her classroom), I thought maybe this was some Marxist critique of capitalism or something, but I couldn’t find that either.
My kid asked for a source for her material (it’s not in the text), and she said that she didn’t have one, but that the handouts should be sufficient to learn. I find it troubling that there appears to be no academic literature or even popular articles on this supposedly well-known axis, and the teacher can’t point to any supporting material other than her own self-made handouts. If anyone can point me to a source so my kid can understand it, I would really appreciate it.
One reason I want to deal with this is that it seems to me that she is actively teaching incorrect concepts to the kids. When they get to university they are going to be horribly confused until they un-learn what she is teaching them. I studied philosophy in college and these definitions of materialism and altruism, their relationship to each other and to political ideologies is completely new to me.
So if anyone would like to take a stab at explaining this before I talk to the teacher, I’d like to hear it!