[QUOTE=MEBuckner]
The warning stands. You directly quoted another poster on this board using the word “calculus”; you say “calculus is such a big word to use for an Iraq war supporter” (which is already pushing it at the very least); then you follow up with “Fools, blackguards and reprobates will remain so, the mission of this board notwithstanding” which definitely puts it over the top. Not even a borderline case, really.
[/QUOTE]
No, I’m sorry but you are plainly mistaken in ordinary functional grammer. This it how it goes:
1: - There is no doubt that the subject of John Mace’s sentence was “someone [who] supported the Iraq war.”
2: - John Mace then raises the ‘calculus’ that person would use
3: - Indicating by “I” that he and others had pointed this out previously.
He and you are not now in a position to claim that this “I” made him the subject, particularly as he expressly pointed out he was not an Iraq war supporter in the thread. Nor did I assume he was an Iraq war supporter in drafting the post.
4: I argued that someone who supported the Iraq war did not merit their thinking process being called ‘calculus’.
[QUOTE=MEBuckner]
Also, if it’s possible to construe a set of words in some extremely contrived and unnatural way such that they don’t technically insult another poster, but (sans lengthy explanation of the supposedly complex grammar) the most obvious interpretation which will be taken by anyone else reading the post is that you just insulted the other poster, I’m going with the reading everyone else will be giving your post.
[/QUOTE]
So do we agree you are wrong if Captain Amazing took my post to refer to Iraq war supporters generally, rather than John Mace personally:
It is not me that has contrived the grammar unnaturally. JM just misread the post.
[QUOTE=MEBuckner]
This is a message board, not a patent infringement lawsuit; the purpose of the rules is to maintain a little civility and decorum so that people can have political arguments without them turning into mindless flame wars or screaming trainwrecks, not to play “Gotcha!” with sentence structure or pronoun antecedents.
[/QUOTE]
I quite agree. Sadly, it is you that has played Gotcha!
I made a legitimate and arguable point which I maintain by the way. John Mace found an insult in it, that in the plain light of day isn’t there. That’s a long way from ‘Direct Personal Insult.’
If you are going to have a rule about ‘questioning the morals of people who advance particular positions’ say so. So I’m touchy about proper grammar, Ok.
But look, I’m fair, I can cool the general tone, there was heat there which seems to me what it’s really about.
Here try this:
“To call an Iraq war supporter’s thinking calculus, is more dignity than it merits.”
How’s that?
To the co-religionist detractors: Contact DSeid, he has worked out the relevant facts. Not at liberty to say more.