Microsoft's Ad Department Needs to be Killed

Yes, I know, Apple has those smugly annoying “I’m a Mac” ads, but I think that everyone can agree this is far, far worse.

That’s bad, and, even if we assume that this was done by an outside company MS signed up and approved the thing for release.

Mind you, putting the camo’d Mac in the ad is stupid, but the ad is some kind of creeping horror, that would give Lovecraft the willies. I made it just a couple seconds into it before I realized that I had two choices: I could stop watching the ad, or I could start stabbing myself with sharp objects. The “acting” falls somewhere below what the guy who does the Sham-WOW ads is capable of, and slightly above that of having your testicles removed with a rusty coke spoon.

Okay, so I get that since its music software, you’ve got to demonstrate it somehow, and with High School musical being “all the rage” amongst the kids these days that you’d want to ape it, and hope that you appeal to the “youth demographic,” but this is not how you fucking do it. This is like someone telling you they’re a songwriter, and when you ask them about what kind of songs they write they respond with, “My latest song is called Jesus is a Traffic Light.” Its a horrifying hard stop, like when you meet that certain special someone, only to discover they’ve got the wrong kind of plumbing. It falls squarely into the catagory of Things Which Should Not Be[sup]TM[/sup].

How the fuck could the people at Microsoft watch this and think, “Yes, this is exactly the kind of image we want our product to project.”? Did no one say, “Look, I realize that this might (somehow) be appealing to kids, but this is so jarringly bad that it taints everything we touch.”? Because, for me, it really does. Now, admittedly, I don’t have a high view of MS to begin with, but thanks to that ad, every time I see a PC ad, I’m going to hear some teenaged girl go, “I’m singing to my laptop.” in my head. Then, I’m going to get all twitchy and people will think I have Tourette’s or something.

Well, that was fun. It made the YouTube browser in my iPhone crash.

Based on my experience making TV commercials, I have come to the conclusion that at the very least 90% of the world’s crack cocaine production is consumed by ad departments. It’s the only sensible explanation to the things I’ve been through.

And they also luuuurve Macs, which would explain why they’d use on for the ad.

I think the ad is hilarious, in a car-wreck kind of way. I started a thread about it in Cafe Society yesterday.

I thought it was mildly entertaining, which is more than I can say for any recent Mac ad, and - more importantly - it makes me think Songsmith could be kind of fun.

And lots of people run Windows programs on Macs.

One thing you should realize is that this is a Microsoft Research project, not a real product they’re trying to sell. Occasionally an application that might be interesting to the public comes out of MSR and they polish it up and release it, but it’s not something they put real marketing behind. I have to admit that the video is kind of painful to watch, but it’s a little easier when you realize that the “actors” are actually MSR researchers that just volunteered to be in the goofy video.

Songsmith will likely never be a real product on its own. I imagine that if they decide people like the technology, they’ll just incorporate it into Windows Movie Maker as a “give your movie a soundtrack” feature or something.

Maybe that’s the point. Make the worst ad ever for an incredibly lame product - and then use your rival’s brand. It’s like John Hodgman’s revenge against Justin Long.

Second this. A lot of us are running Windows XP on a Mac.

My first thought was that it was from The Onion.

Hilariously bad, but I couldn’t watch the whole thing.

Yes, using Parallels, BootCamp, and VMWare Fusion, but one would think that if MS is trying to emphasize the Windows only aspect of the product, they’d put it on a machine which can only run Windows.

I thought it was really funny.

I thought it was pretty clear that they intentionally used a Mac. Just like they intentionally made it awful. Viral marketing.

Microsoft products are so bad they even make a Mac suck?

Saw this on Digg last night. It’s unbelievably horrible, yet I couldn’t help but watch to the end, because I was in such disbelief over the crappiness of it. Like another poster above, it seemed like it was from The Onion.

If you were unaware that I am a developer for Mac PowerPoint, then that’s a pretty accidentally funny thing to say to me.

If you were aware, fuck you. :slight_smile:

Morbo only pawn in game of life.

This isn’t as terrible as when Gmail made that ad about the “island of lost e-mails” using letter-puppets, so I can only presume that CS geeks producing commercials could have done worse.

Why them?
I can turn off/mute the ads when I see them. I can’t do that with all the bugs and security holes in their software. Let’s kill their coding (or testing) department instead.

Just came back to report, I’ve discovered I’m completely full of it on this particular project. It is actually for sale. I take back my defense of the low production values of the commercial (except I do know for certain that at least one person in it was a random geek from MSR, not a real actor, because he’s a friend of mine).